I suppose I shouldn't be afraid of an unpopular opinion. Let me preface all this by saying that I understand it. Peters is a rising star in the coaching community and a guy that is getting a lot more exposure and love from virtually every direction. He's a fantastic coach for his style. He was able to come into this situation and do what Paul Maurice wasn't entirely able. Full marks for that.
However, he's a trap/possession coach. The system that he runs requires players to fit a certain stylistic identity that may not suit their abilities. Going back in time a bit, it's like when Laviolette built his team to his specifications to the extent that he was essentially the only one that could coach that group. And when he began to falter in terms of keeping the room together, they had to break down and start from scratch. I think when Maurice came in, there was an attempt made to change the system but it never really caught. There were too many guys on this team that weren't going to buy in and it resulted in some really confusing hockey to watch. The difference with Peters is that, by now, he's the only coach these guys have had at the NHL level and the buy in is already established. What concerns me is that with the massive influx of offensive talent we've gained by some shrewd drafting and trading, we may be giving Peters players that he doesn't know how to play. There might even be *too* much interchangeability to forwards in this system. In the NHL, you need at least one line that is going to go out there and push offense and take chances. Is Peters capable of allowing that to take place if it's the best choice for the team or will he squash it because it sets a bad example for players going off script to create offense? I don't know. But early returns on that haven't been encouraging. Jeff Skinner has seemed almost apathetic at times during Peters' tenure, presumably for being pushed to be more of a two-way forward. Elias Lindholm has consistently looked afraid to create his own shots. Sometimes you need to let the horses run. At some point in the not so distant future, Peters is going to have to make a decision. We have some exciting young offensive minded forwards. With as strong as the development curve has been for defensemen (sans Murphy, notice anything about that?), it has been almost equally bad with forwards. Rask might be the only guy that has had an upward swing in his career arc and it's partially because Peters style and Rask's abilities are almost perfectly aligned. What can we expect from guys like Teuvo, Lindholm, Aho, Saarela, Tolchinsky, etc. under Bill Peters? That's what concerns me. Great coaches make adjustments when their personnel no longer requires them to coach a certain way to keep games close. Hopefully, Peters will be able to make that adjustment. As it stands right now, it only seems as though Peters has asked his players to adjust without exception. That concerns me.