Confirmed with Link: Callum Booth Signs Entry Level Deal

[MinJaBen]

i worded it wrong. I mean as in prospect wise. Yes you give a good example but the thing is most people still have ned as a better prospect. but yes the future is unpredictable. We took a risk on murphy then put him in the nhl to soon. It was our management's fault on ruining him. Slavin was give time to develop. Also ned looked extremely solid in net at the nhl level by getting a penalty, us killing it off, (getting on the scoreboard) and saved every shot. we haven't seen that with Booth yet.

I think this is a myth. Ryan has had way more time in OUR system to develop when compared to Slavin. Slavin was older when he got to us because he stayed in college longer compared to Murphy, but Murphy has had much more time at the AHL level to try and learn the game. Slavin is just better. The three guys out playing Murphy who joined the team last year probably have less combined time in the AHL than Murphy. They just are better players. Management didn't ruin Murphy...Murphy ruined Murphy.

 

[Boom Boom Apathy]

i worded it wrong. I mean as in prospect wise. Yes you give a good example but the thing is most people still have ned as a better prospect. but yes the future is unpredictable. We took a risk on murphy then put him in the nhl to soon. It was our management's fault on ruining him. Slavin was give time to develop. Also ned looked extremely solid in net at the nhl level by getting a penalty, us killing it off, (getting on the scoreboard) and saved every shot. we haven't seen that with Booth yet.

Your post went from bad to worse. Where a guy was drafted does not automatically mean he's a better prospect 2-3 years post draft, which is what you are implying.

Secondly, the Canes didn't "ruin" Murphy by putting him in the NHL too soon.

Drafted 2011
Post draft +1: Stayed in CHL
Post draft +2: Stayed in CHL
Post draft +3: Split between NHL / AHL
Post draft +4: Split between NHL / AHL
Post draft +5: Split between NHL / AHL
Post draft +6: Fully NHL

Slavin
Drafted 2012
Post draft +1: Stayed in USHL
Post draft +2: NCAA
Post draft +3: NCAA
Post draft +4: Full time NHL (only 14 AHL games)

So post draft, Slavin played 142 games in lower leauges before becoming an NHL regular (USHL, NCAA + 14 AHL). Post draft, Murphy has played 185 games in lower leagues (103 CHL, 82 AHL).

 

[Joe McGrath]

I think this is a myth. Ryan has had way more time in OUR system to develop when compared to Slavin. Slavin was older when he got to us because he stayed in college longer compared to Murphy, but Murphy has had much more time at the AHL level to try and learn the game. Slavin is just better. The three guys out playing Murphy who joined the team last year probably have less combined time in the AHL than Murphy. They just are better players. Management didn't ruin Murphy...Murphy ruined Murphy.

I think the ***** who scrambled Murphy's brain in juniors ruined him TBH.

 

[FaulkYouAho]

I think the ***** who scrambled Murphy's brain in juniors ruined him TBH.

this is an excellent theory and i haven't really kept up with his stats scince he became a bust. I thought slavin played more than him tho. idk why i was thinking that

 

[Navin R Slavin]

Also ned looked extremely solid in net at the nhl level by getting a penalty, us killing it off, (getting on the scoreboard) and saved every shot. we haven't seen that with Booth yet.

Also jorge alves looked extremely solid in net at the nhl level by getting 8 seconds and perfect gaa. we haven't seen that with Booth yet.

 

[Unsustainable]

Your post went from bad to worse. Where a guy was drafted does not automatically mean he's a better prospect 2-3 years post draft, which is what you are implying.

Secondly, the Canes didn't "ruin" Murphy by putting him in the NHL too soon.

Drafted 2011
Post draft +1: Stayed in CHL
Post draft +2: Stayed in CHL
Post draft +3: Split between NHL / AHL
Post draft +4: Split between NHL / AHL
Post draft +5: Split between NHL / AHL
Post draft +6: Fully NHL

Slavin
Drafted 2012
Post draft +1: Stayed in USHL
Post draft +2: NCAA
Post draft +3: NCAA
Post draft +4: Full time NHL (only 14 AHL games)

So post draft, Slavin played 142 games in lower leauges before becoming an NHL regular (USHL, NCAA + 14 AHL). Post draft, Murphy has played 185 games in lower leagues (103 CHL, 82 AHL).

Solid analysis.
#solid

 

[tarheelhockey]

I think the ***** who scrambled Murphy's brain in juniors ruined him TBH.

Considering how contact-averse he is, this might really be as good of an explanation as we're going to get.