I posted this elsewhere, but it is useful here too.
Bolland played 15 games for us... that's it. Pretty hard to say he is a critical part of our future, and success, particularly when our pre-Olympic record was 11-2-1.
He's had a serious injury, and may never fully recover from it. He is such a valuable player, that Chicago had him on the 4th line, and gave up on him for the 51st, 117th in the 2013 NHL Entry Draft and a fourth rounder in the 2014 Draft. Heart and Soul local boy, sure, whatever...
Over the last few years he's played 39/82 games, 61/82 games, 76/82 games, 35/48 games, 15/60 games.
Chicago traded him, because he was marginally useful for them at his current cap hit, oft injured, and knew he would be asking more than they would pay him, for his value. Chicago didn't think that he was a key to winning the cup, and traded him for a few lower picks.
I get wanting to win now, but I'd rather try and get Statsny at $6.5 million, than Bolland at $5 million.
He is just not worth $5 million in this cap era, not at about .5ppg average over the last few seasons... +- (not an exact calculation), when he misses a ton of games, and we've adjusted and done well without him. He is basically an unknown as to what you are going to get with him, post-injury.
I'd say keep him, but he isn't getting anywhere near $5 million unless he set's the world on fire on our way to the Stanley Cup finals.
Frankly I think 2-3 years at $4 million is my max... particularly when you've got Holland improving, and then Gauthier probably ready in 3 years to join the team.