Proposal: Blues and Tampa Bay

[Dr Quincy]

Petro (50% retained), Schmaltz, Perunovich, and Sanford

for

Sergachev, Foote, Raddysh, Stevens, and a first round pick 2019

Way too big a deal. Nobody is giving up those combined collection of assets in a deal.

 

[DownIsTheNewUp]

Correct, Tampa can’t trade their 2nd or 1st in 2019

Couldn't they still trade the picks with the opposite conditions?

In other words, the deal with the Rangers involves their 2nd round pick, on the condition that if they win the cup this season that pick becomes the 1st rounder.

Couldn't they still trade their 1st round pick in another deal, on the condition that if they win the cup this season that pick becomes their 2nd rounder?

 

[VoluntaryDom]

Petro (50% retained), Schmaltz, Perunovich, and Sanford

for

Sergachev, Foote, Raddysh, Stevens, and a first round pick 2019

NOPE

 

[God King Fudge]

Deal as proposed in OP would completely gut TB.

I'd love to add Petro because Hedman-Stralman/McDonagh-Cernak/Petro-Coburn is absolutely outlandish, but the cost would just be too high, especially with Point needing a raise soon.

Moving Sergachev in the deal eliminates some future concern because you don't have to worry about whatever impending payday he has coming up, but between the asset cost and the cost of the actual contract, I don't see it really working.

 

[DictatorTots427]

Foote + Raddysh + Ingram + Johnson + 2020 1st for Petro

 

[AndreRoy]

Foote + Raddysh + Ingram + Johnson + 2020 1st for Petro

Have you read anything that has been said in this thread? Hell no. This is beyond laughable.

 

[DistantThunderRep]

Have you read anything that has been said in this thread? Hell no. This is beyond laughable.

I think they forgot the sarcasm emoji.

 

[SC2GM]

Where do I sign, on the Blues behalf? Let's get er done.

 

[Whitsmith803]

Pietrangelo, Alex 6.5 (extends 7m/6yrs)
Bozak, Tyler 5
Walman, Jake

Miller, J.T. 5.25
Callahan, Ryan 5.8
Koekkoek, Slater
Foote, Cal

 

[DFC]

Pietrangelo, Alex 6.5 (extends 7m/6yrs)
Bozak, Tyler 5
Walman, Jake

Miller, J.T. 5.25
Callahan, Ryan 5.8
Koekkoek, Slater
Foote, Cal

TB can't do this. You're pretty much taking exactly the cap we're looking to get rid of, and replacing it with more cap. Petro would be waaaaay beyond a luxury at this point.

There's no deal to be done here. Our D is already as good as it can get in a cap era.

 

[byrath]

We wouldn’t give up Foote for Karlsson or McDonagh - we sure as hell aren’t giving up him AND Sergachev (plus all the other pieces) for Petro. Not to mention that Petro is currently on LTIR and it’s uncertain when he’ll return or how well he will play at that point, that his cap hit even with 50% retention would kill us next season when it comes to resigning Point, that we already have two #1Ds and are in zero need of another, that all of the other pieces you offered us are garbage and unneeded...I could go on and on but frankly I’ve got better things to do. YOUR PROPOSAL SUCKS - accept that fact and go away.

A little harsh, but I pretty much agree with you. Tampa does not need Petro, and Sanford+Schmaltz are fringe NHL'ers, not 'NHL ready prospects' imo.
A shame that rumored/speculated Shatty for Johnson trade never happened though.

 

[CupsOverCash]

TB cant take on a player like Petro without giving back some significant cap that there is no way the Blues would consider doing it. Would have to be something like Miller, Callahan, Palat/Johnson for Petro. Which would take away some significant depth that we have at the forward position. Give to get but I dont see why either team would do it.

 

[LTIR Trickery]

Petro (50% retained), Schmaltz, Perunovich, and Sanford

for

Sergachev, Foote, Raddysh, Stevens, and a first round pick 2019

This is hilarious.

 

[LTIR Trickery]

Foote + Raddysh + Ingram + Johnson + 2020 1st for Petro

This might be worse. At least the initial retained salary.

 

[DictatorTots427]

Have you read anything that has been said in this thread? Hell no. This is beyond laughable.

This might be worse. At least the initial retained salary.

I proposed almost the exact same thing for Karlsson to Tampa and was told it was not nearly enough going to Ottawa. Are Karlsson and Petro really that far apart in value?

 

[LTIR Trickery]

I proposed almost the exact same thing for Karlsson to Tampa and was told it was not nearly enough going to Ottawa. Are Karlsson and Petro really that far apart in value?

I don't care about the Ottawa stuff, you're asking for our best F, D, G prospects plus a roster center for your top six and a pick?

 

[AndreRoy]

I proposed almost the exact same thing for Karlsson to Tampa and was told it was not nearly enough going to Ottawa. Are Karlsson and Petro really that far apart in value?

Look at what Karlsson actually returned and then reevaluate the proposal you made.

Not to mention the fact that we neither need nor can afford Petro even at 50% retention, which makes any proposal superfluous.

 

[AndreRoy]

Pietrangelo, Alex 6.5 (extends 7m/6yrs)
Bozak, Tyler 5
Walman, Jake

Miller, J.T. 5.25
Callahan, Ryan 5.8
Koekkoek, Slater
Foote, Cal

Another person who didn’t read the thread and apparently can’t do simple arithmetic. We’re in a cap crunch and you want us to add a massive amount of longterm cap while subtracting our top defensive prospect who offers invaluable cost-controlled ELC years?

It’s very simple people: we’re trading Miller for futures and either trading or buying out Callahan (if we don’t simply allow him to play out his contract); Foote is NOT for sale and we do NOT need or want Petro.

 

[simon IC]

I do not see a deal between these two teams.

 

[SC29681]

Blues fans seem to think they have two RHD Parayko and Pietrangelo that instantly transform a team into true Cup contender, Has never done fulfilled the Blues Cup expectations. IMO, this "one player" that puts a team over the top just isn't true.

That depends on how close the receiving team is to the Cup.

 

[DFC]

I proposed almost the exact same thing for Karlsson to Tampa and was told it was not nearly enough going to Ottawa. Are Karlsson and Petro really that far apart in value?

...And then Karlsson got way, way, way less.

 

[westc2]

Our #1 dman and 2 good young players for............ a bunch of junk and a very late 1st rounder?

 

[Leonardo87]

Pietrangelo, Alex 6.5 (extends 7m/6yrs)
Bozak, Tyler 5
Walman, Jake

Miller, J.T. 5.25
Callahan, Ryan 5.8
Koekkoek, Slater
Foote, Cal

Callahan does not have St. Louis on his trade list.

 

[AndreRoy]

Our #1 dman and 2 good young players for............ a bunch of junk and a very late 1st rounder?

Keep your crap and we’ll keep our players - problem solved. This thread consists of Blues fans trying to force a trade on us that we have zero interest in.

 

[Shoresy Snipes]

Callahan does not have St. Louis on his trade list.

Where is his trade list?