Would do it as a habs fan, but only if that 1st pick is top 10 protected. If it's a top 10 pick this year + Poehling + 2nd + the potential for another second and whatever they can get for shaw... I think we are getting screwed.
For a pick in the 15 range I think it's a fair trade.
With the addition of Toews at the moment without taking anything significant from our lineup pretty guarantee us a wild card spot. That would allow us to put Domi back at wing and someone to take on Danault current spot in the lineup. I could see something like:
Tatar - Toews - Gallagher
Domi - Kotkaniemi - Drouin
Lehkonen - Danault - Armia
Byron - Chaput - Whatever
Toews would be an enormous add for us. He's basically only -3 on a -30ish team and is on pace for around 65 points this year. Add to that his defensive and FO ability and this change the look of our franchise for the next 4-5 years minimum while Price/Weber are still in their prime and Gallagher/Drouin on a cheap contract.
We still would have Mete/Brook/Suzuki/Fleury coming up and contributing on ELC within that time-frame. Also, for Kotkaniemi to have a guy like Toews as a mentor would be huge for his career.