For me it depends on what it takes. My view is the 1st round pick and Necas are completely off limits in a rental type situation, especially if we are barely holding on to the last WC spot. I realize there are more options than just rentals, but for reference, here is a list of some of the UFAs that might be available based on the assumption that their team may not be competing for a playoff spot. A thing I forget sometimes is that we will be getting Stempniak back. He's streaky, but he's been a 40 point player the last few years.
Sedin's
Plekanec
E. Kane
Filppula
Backlund
Stajan
Vrbata
Maroon
Vanek
Versteeg
Jagr
Goalies
Chad Johnson
Antti Ranta
Good and informative post! Thanks for that.
With my knowledge of these players, my opinions would be the following:
Sedin’s = maybe, but probably not worth it, too much on the decline already
Plekanec = maybe, not sure though if he has enough of heart for me to want him to the Canes
E. Kane = a definite NO, a bad attitude and a selfish player, would need his own puck if he would play for the Canes
Filppula = maybe, although I’m not really a fan of his, not at least selfish at all, and could be maybe useful as a third line player, quite mediocre puck handling skills, but good attitude and relatively good hockey IQ
Backlund = a definite YES, very useful player from the Canes perspective
Stajan = maybe, I have not followed him as a player enough to have a clear opinion on him
Vrbata = quite possible yes, I think he could be a useful and potentially productive player for the Canes
Maroon = I don’t think so, pretty bad skater whom is also a pretty much on/off player, don’t see much of use for him in the Canes
Vanek = pretty much a no no, quite much a power play specialist whose defensive play and skating are that questionable that I wouldn’t really want him in the Canes
Versteeg = probably yes, he seems like he could be a pretty useful 3rd or even 4th liner, and if needed, he could relatively well substitute for top six players missing in action
Jagr = he is the greatest European player of all time, and I have the biggest respect for his career, still a huge NO, as his time in hockey as a player has passed and I see absolutely no use for him in the Canes
Johnson = quite a big maybe, somehow I have a feeling that he wouldn’t be any better for the Canes than Darling has been, but you never know for sure with goalies, sometimes a team change can radically jumpstart a goalie’s career, maybe worth a try if he is available
Raanta = a definite YES, a very quick and agile goalie, although a bit small though, I think he is anyway very good and has the potential to be amazing in a defensively good team that the Canes definitely are, he is also used to playing most of his NHL career as a number two goalie, so I don’t think that having to compete for the number one spot with Ward would be that strange for him. Could make a very nice duo with Ward, and could maybe even take the number one goalie spot gradually, he would be a great signing in my opinion anyway
Of course these are only my personal opinions and I perfectly understand if people disagree with me, but if you do, would be nice to hear a bit more about the reasons why you disagree about any of these players?
Oh, and of course Tavares would be a jackpot, and also Stempniak could be a pretty useful player for the Canes. Personally I think that after Tavares Raanta would be the next best signing that the Canes could really do, but very interested to hear other opinions!