Big Phil
Registered User
- Nov 2, 2003
- 31,703
- 4,148
Alright this will be a different poll. Who was the best goalie to never win the Cup? I have taken Tony Esposito out of the equation because even though he only played 13 games in '69 for the Habs - and no playoff games, Vachon and Worsley did - he was still credited with a Cup win.
So off the top of my head it comes down to two guys and if you think I'm wrong please specify who was better, you'll have the option of a third party.
Was it Eddie Giacomin? Two first team all-stars, 3 2nd team all-star, one Vezina, one Cup final appearance.
Or Curtis Joseph? No Vezinas, no first team all-star, no 2nd team all-stars no Cup finals appearances. One Olympic Gold, lost '96 World Cup.
So off the top of my head it comes down to two guys and if you think I'm wrong please specify who was better, you'll have the option of a third party.
Was it Eddie Giacomin? Two first team all-stars, 3 2nd team all-star, one Vezina, one Cup final appearance.
Or Curtis Joseph? No Vezinas, no first team all-star, no 2nd team all-stars no Cup finals appearances. One Olympic Gold, lost '96 World Cup.