There seems two be two camps evolving in NYI fanbase, I for one hope we keep JT and Barzal. It's not one or the other to me, with that being said, Barzal is much more impressive on a nightly basis.
Comparing their rookie seasons is not giving JT a fair shake since Barzal does have much better teammates. I feel Barzal's skating makes him the better player moving forward, now JT is still the man and #1C but should he stay with the team, I wouldn't be surprised for their roles to shift as JT gets older and Barzal enters his physical peak in say 2 or 3 years. Either way, as long as we got that 1-2 punch we'll be in good shape up front.
It is a SPEED game, Barzal was built for this.