If this isn't a review of the season then what is the point in basing votes on how they performed last season if they stepped on the ice right now?
I understood this as if the season would've started when the poll was made (during the rest of the playoffs), who would have been the best player on our roster back then.
So Downie doesn't count cause he was traded for Talbot.
Benoit and Staz count cause they were technically still on our roster.
But as I said before, I think 11 is a fine number to end this with. I don't see the point in deciding if Wilson or Guenin is the better player.