Kenora THISTLES
1907 Stanley Cup Champions
Home Rink: Thistle Rink (1920), Kenora, Ontario
GM's: papershoes & SchultzSquared
Coach: Viktor Tikhonov
Assistant Coach: Harry Sinden
Captain: Niklas Lidstrom
Alternates: Dale Hawerchuk, Ted Harris, Igor Larionov
#17 Valery Kharlamov - #10 Dale Hawerchuk (A) - #8 Ken Hodge
#9 Vladimir Krutov - #11 Igor Larionov (A) - #24 Sergei Makarov
Hec Kilrea - #21 Doug Jarvis - #15 Eric Nesterenko
Johnny Wilson - Paul Ronty - #14 Rene Robert
extra: Gary Unger
#5 Niklas Lidstrom (C) - #2 Cy Wentworth
#5 Alexander Ragulin - Babe Pratt
Ian Turnbull - #10 Ted Harris (A)
extra: Benny Woit (D/RW)
Hap Holmes
Viktor Konovalenko
Ryan Miller
Powerplay:
PP1: Valery Kharlamov - Dale Hawerchuk - Sergei Makarov - Niklas Lidstrom - Rene Robert
PP2: Vladimir Krutov - Igor Larionov - Ken Hodge - Babe Pratt - Ian Turnbull
Penalty Kill:
PK1: Doug Jarvis - Eric Nesterenko - Niklas Lidstrom - Alexander Ragulin
PK2: Igor Larionov - Hec Kilrea - Ted Harris - Cy Wentworth
Coaching
Tikhonov is a below average coach IMO. One good thing is that I don't think you have any players that will clash with his very strict/tough style, so he works in that way. I'm not really sure how Sinden fits in here, and I would like some info on how you will use him. Tikhonov is not a line matching guy at all, and it seems like that contradicts your 3rd line, which is designed as a shutdown line. It seems like they would be wasted a bit whenever they don't get matched up against your opponents' best.
Leadership
No complaints here, Lidstrom is a strong leader that will definitely do what he's told. He has good support from the alternates.
Forwards
First Line: Kharlamov-Hawerchuk is a good combo. I think you could've done better than Hodge to complete the line. A guy like Odie Cleghorn would've worked well and brought more toughness which I think is needed. Also, Hodge may have trouble keeping up with his linemates.
Second Line: Not much to say here, you reunited the great KLM line. These guys will be a force, and one of the very best second lines in the draft.
Third Line: A good defensive line, but as I said before, they may be under-utilized in Tikhonov's system.
Fourth Line: An average 4th line, not much to say here.
Overall: The first 2 lines seem to fit in a Tikhonov type team, but I would've liked to have seen a more two-way 3rd line. Lack of toughness on the first 2 lines may be an issue against some teams.
Defense
First Pair: Lidstrom is an elite #1, but Wentworth is just an average to above average #4 in my mind. They will be good defensively, but usually Lidstrom gets paired with a more offensive guy, so you are losing out on that. These guys are also lacking size, which could be an issue against physical lines that put big guys in front of the net.
Second Pair: I am definitely not a fan of where Ragulin usually gets drafted. He gets drafted like he's a high-end #3, but I think he's more of an average to above average #4. I don't value the 60's Soviets very highly, and he doesn't have many accomplishments in the 70's, which is when I do start to value them. Pratt is an average to below average #3, these guys bring a lot of toughness, and the two fit well together stylistically, so the pairing as a whole works.
Third Pair: Good pairing. Harris is a high-end #5, and the two complement each other well.
Overall: The first pairing could have been constructed better with either a tougher/bigger guy or a more offensive guy. You could bring up Pratt, but Lidstrom has said himself that the only thing he asks for is to have a RHS partner, which Pratt is not. There would also be a real lack of puck-moving on the 2nd pairing. There's no perfect solution here, you will just have to pick whichever setup you think is the lesser of two evils.
Goaltending
Easily the weakest part of your team. Holmes is a low-end starter, and you didn't get him a very good backup, which I think you should have. I don't really think having 3 goalies will help much either...I think that would be more helpful if you had guys with health issues. I think you should drop one of your backups and pick up a spare that can play wing, because right now you don't have someone to fill in there.
Special Teams
Powerplay: A ton of firepower and skill up front, no net guy, but I think you have so much skill that it doesn't matter. Lidstrom is great on the point. My one question is Robert...Did he regularly play the point on the PP? I'm not saying he didn't, I just don't know, and would like some evidence or for some of the other GM's to back it up. I don't remember him being a PP point guy last year. (EDIT: Confirmed that he did). I would suggest leaving your forward PP units as is against teams with good 1st and 2nd PK units, but if you run into a team with a weak 2nd unit you may want to just play them how they are at ES, which is more Tikhonov's style anyway.
Penalty Kill: Outstanding first unit and very good second unit as well. Outside of Holmes, this is very strong.
Overall: Strong special teams
Summary
Tons of firepower on the first two lines, but lacking a little in toughness. The third line is a good shutdown type line, but line matching doesn't fit the coach's style. As a group the D will be very sound defensively, but I think the first pairing could've been constructed in a way to better complement your forwards. Goaltending is a weakness. Pretty strong special teams. This team will likely be a problem for teams that only have one forward line that is good defensively or that have slow defensemen.