Moved the discussion to a more appropriate thread. Didn't have time to answer earlier but I wanted to quote the 2 posters below
Yeah they blew their wad to win while Their defense and goaltending,arent yet in decline...But having a them all over 30 means they likely will have a few lean years coming up soon
Bergevin is very patient, probably more than some fans would want but progressively worked on the roster, made the moves required and finally spent before Price, Weber, Petry, etc get "too old"
It seems that some people think that Montreal is in this situation because of good drafting but it is really NOT the case... They only have 4 drafted players in the lineup. Their drafting has sucked for a long time. The roster is basically all trades and UFA signings.
They are not close to "decline" but as I have talked about, Tatar, Danault, Armia and Kotkaniemi will need a new contract next season (but they are already against the cap) and Suzuki the following season. Tough choices will have to be made. And then you have other players that will continue to get older.
If we're looking at a 3-5 year window, you need to include Drouin (25), Anderson (26), Gallagher (28) and Toffoli (27) all of whom, with the exception of Drouin, are signed for at least 3 more seasons.
Either way, I certainly agree that we probably have a more impressive crop of U-25 names and prospects.
But the bulk of Montreal's roster isn't all that close to aging out, so I wouldn't expect them to go away anytime soon. In a division with Montreal, Toronto and Tampa - we're going to be in tough. Hopefully we can make the jump from having a lot of prospects to actually assembling a good NHL team in the next year or two, like Montreal has.
And yes, I predicted Montreal to be behind Toronto, Winnipeg and Calgary in the North. I also thought Matt Murray was a good acquisition and Stepan had some juice left in his tank. Shows how much I know.
I was not talking about their window when you replied to me, you are confounding me with another poster. I was simply comparing the youth. And yeah, it goes without saying that I was certainly not thinking about 27+ y/o players when talking about "youth", even if it's not "old" by any means. You can include Drouin (26 y/o in March) if you want but he's not that big of a piece. He's basically a Hoffman without the elite shot. Pretty shiny player though. I think he will be gone in the offseason as they need to make some cap space.
I also never said that the "bulk of Montreal's roster was close to aging out". This is what I have said just above when I quoted you
"All that being said, they might not go downhill too fast. "Older" players can still be useful in the right system, with a good mix of young players and an efficient leadership/coaching staff. In Montreal, vets become better when they get there. In Ottawa, it's the opposite."
So everything was already addressed, I'm just repeating. You probably mixed my posts with topshelf15
Finally this was my prediction on January 14th :
1. Montreal
2. Toronto
3. Vancouver
4. Winnipeg
5. Calgary
6. Edmonton
7. Ottawa
That's two players...
Suzuki, Kotkaniemi, Romanov, Anderson, Toffoli, Gallagher... they all have 5 good years left, at least. And in nets, Cayden Primeau is waiting in the wings and in 3-4 years, when he's 24-25, should be ready to step in.
Of course nothing is guaranteed, but they seem to have struck a pretty good balance in having a shot to win now while maintaining a bright long-term future.
As an Ottawa fan, I'm jealous.
Wow that's a quick change of heart
Canadian Division Predictions