Honestly it’s like they play to prove Berger and the rest of the media wrong more than they play to max their chances of winning.
“They’re too soft”
They start running around getting suspended
“The defense can’t defend”
They play offense scared and start losing 2-1 goalie duels instead
“They can’t score playoff goals”
Most of the offense is now designed around one of Tavares and Matthews deflecting shots and digging for pucks in front of the net.
You can’t have a coherent identity if your identity is proving someone wrong or being the opposite of something, they need to pick positive values and ideals and commit to them regardless of what outside pressure is telling them to do.
That is why I got upset as soon as they started bringing up "killer instinct". That led to bringing in a bunch of underwhelming vets and physical guys meant to bring "character" only for them to be underwhelming players on the ice that simply could not be trusted.
And then the same thing about not paying big for rentals. It was a good idea because paying big for rentals almost never pays off (and I say this after ROR and Gio actually provided pretty good value as big rentals and we ended up keeping Gio around on a reasonable deal).
We tried so hard to emulate other teams that we just ended up being cheap copies of them. Like it is good that you try to learn from other successful teams, but ultimately we are not going to win the same way.
It is kind of funny that a lot of the things that Dubas "learned" from experience were arguably some of his worst decisions when had he stayed the course and kept building on skill, we maybe would have had some better teams. I still think he built really good teams that should have done much better than they did, but that always seemed cringey to me.
We'll see what Treliving does, but let's just hope he doesn't try to copy Calgary... Because that didn't exactly work out too well.
Maybe Phil needs to come back and hopefully he can rub his winning ways to the other boys.
He wouldn't come back for the media (and possibly the fans) alone. Probably has no problem with the city and the team.