Phil is washed up and can't do anything besides score. And by score I mean eating hot dogs.
Kessel doesn’t play defense at all and is slow as f***. Toronto basically just lived with his negative goal differential.
Mike Sullivan knew how to use him while maintaining strong team defense. He stopped using him on Malkin’s line and he often sheltered him like a wounded baby bird on third line with scrubs, only occasionally letting him play with Malkin and mainly let him destroy people on mismatches and the PP.
That stopped working as well after two years because they lost Nick Bonino. It was shakier in 2017-18 because the Penguins had depth issues (Riley Sheahan is bad at hockey) so he had to play with Malkin more and was exposed more but got close to the original success with whatever random scrubs were around in 2018-19 (probably Aston-Reese).
The problem is we aren’t a veteran team with a strong team defense and some strong defensive forwards who can be put on Phil babysitting duty. We had a place to put Gusev, but there’s no equivalent of Zajac/Coleman checking line now. He can’t play on either top two lines, he’s so much of a defensive liability that his goal-scoring isn’t likely worth much. He also would likely drive everyone on this board bonkers.
The other part is cost. He’s only costing the Coyotes 1m in salary, they already paid him his 5m signing bonus, so they aren’t going to eager to dump him. He has 8 team trade list too, which isn’t much so there’s that.