I feel like people just didn't want to try something new.
McLean is more knowledgeable overall but that means nothing when you're constantly trying to inject your ego and agenda into things. And how is anyone supposed to get to that level to take over for him? He's not going to be able to do this forever.
Strombo IS very good at facilitating discussion and even though the rest of the guys are idiots he had more of a buddy connection with them than McLean ever has.
If all you're doing is swapping Strombo and McLean, it's not significantly improving the broadcast IMO. And if you think thousands of viewers are going to tune in to watch McLean host you're sorely mistaken.
Yup. I was against the change when it happened, largely I think because I feared losing the 'feel' of HNIC which I strongly associated with McLean - even though I was still pretty choked about the Burrows thing.
But Strombo actually turned out much better than I expected, and when I saw McLean on that Hometown Hockey garbage I realized how annoying I found his fake folksiness and agenda-making.
Pretty disappointed by this, actually. The problem is the panel and the yammering idiots there, and that doesn't look like it'll change
_________
I'll probably take some heat for this, but as the most anti-Messier person imaginable, I actually thought he did really well in a TV setting when doing some intermission stuff with Strombo earlier this year on a couple occasions. He's still a ******, but was intelligent and well-spoken, and the sort of talking head with NHL experience that these panels need, not Nick Kypreos and Damien Cox.