db23 said:
It would be a long trip for me to see the development camp. Not that I wouldn't like to. The guy asked for an opinion on Kastitsyn. You gave one, others offered theirs, I gave mine. You can't expect them all to agree. Saying a prospect has 50% chance of playing in the NHL isn't really "bashing" him. His first year at a higher level of competition wasn't very successful which would lead most to think that his talent level may have been overrated. He did not get along with his coach, which would lead to you to wonder about his attitiude. I think there are legitimate questions both his skill and his attitude. Perhaps those will be answered soon, and I would be quite happy to be proven wrong.
Yes but over the months you seem to go out of your way to put down Kastsitsyn, even though you've never seen him. Everyone is entitled to their opinion, it's just hard to take some people serious when they repeat the same thing over and over.
As for his year in the RSL, yes in 11 games, 1 point is not good, even though it was on the 4th line. If you look back at that time Zherdev was in a major scoring slump as he went goal less for a long strech. His numbers were brutal after such a great season last year. Zherdev on went to play very well in the NHL. I'm not saying Kastsitsyn will have any success at all in the NHL, just that numbers don't tell all, especially considering it's only 11 games on the 4th line. Outside of the RSL, he was close to a goal a game in the 1st league, helped CSKA-2 win the championship, took part in his 4th U-20 tournament and can play in this years as well, took part in his 3rd World Championship team, both winning their divisions and he was one of the top scorers on both teams, and winning the EEHL championship while in Belarus getting ready for the WC's.
For all his positives, there are also downsides. His offensive game is special, but his defensive game is so poor. As for attiude, look no further then his coach who has been called one of the most difficult coaches to play for in hockey. (I don't think Mike Keenan ever punched his star player in gut)
Hopefully Kastsitsyn is signed so we can get a good look at what he can do. I've only seen him twice, but he was very fun to watch in those games.