Speculation: All Star Game

Mayor Bee

Registered User
Dec 29, 2008
18,085
531
Let's get Boll in :yo:

My plan for 2013 was to have a movement to get Klesla and Prospal in, since both were obviously on their last legs and unlikely to get another chance.

I even had bitmap campaign posters and logos and everything ready to go.
 

Viqsi

"that chick from Ohio"
Oct 5, 2007
53,797
31,225
40N 83W (approx)
My plan for 2013 was to have a movement to get Klesla and Prospal in, since both were obviously on their last legs and unlikely to get another chance.

I even had bitmap campaign posters and logos and everything ready to go.
Yet another thing the lockout stole from us. :(
 

Mayor Bee

Registered User
Dec 29, 2008
18,085
531
Going through the rest of the league, there's only one logical person to stuff the ballot box for: Derek MacKenzie. Here's why.

1) I'm a longtime proponent of the Commissioner's Choice selections that existed during the 1990s. These served as a way to put players into the game who may have been overlooked or were at the end of the line and unlikely to make it in otherwise. Picks included HOFers at the end of long careers (Bryan Trottier, Larry Robinson, Mark Messier), players who were generally underrated during their careers and approaching the end (Dale Hunter, Tony Granato), and players whose value to their teams eluded the stats sheet (Brad Marsh, Craig MacTavish).

2) The NHL used to have miscellaneous players in the skills competition, giving them a chance to showcase their skills against the best in the world. Who could forget guys like Stu Grimson and Jon Rohloff rubbing elbows with Wayne Gretzky and Ray Bourque?

MacKenzie would simply be a continuation of these established traditions.

3) We'd be hypocrites to not vote for someone like MacKenzie. The media lauds team-first players who will do "whatever it takes". We all eat up the idea of the quiet player who will do anything to help his team win, whether killing penalties or sacrificing his offensive opportunities to play shutdown defense. We point to these players and say "That is what hockey is all about." Yet when All-Star time comes, we all vote for the superlatively skilled players and shove aside the quiet ones whose game escapes the spotlight.

MacKenzie, in many ways, is the very type of player who should be lauded. He was a 5th-round pick of the Atlanta Thrashers, who were so poorly managed that they could read through a stack of Superman comic books and never figure out the connection to Clark Kent. After years of being shuttled between the NHL and the AHL, including captaining the Chicago Wolves to the Calder Cup Finals, he wasn't qualified and was picked up by Columbus. He spent 7 years in Columbus, anchoring the fourth line and doing everything that was demanded of him. Fill in on a higher line for an injured player? Get MacKenzie out there. Need a defensive zone faceoff with 30 seconds left against a 6-on-4? MacKenzie, take the draw.

His career was almost ended twice, once due to a severely broken ankle and once due to a severe concussion. He persevered, knowing that being a first-line player in the NHL wasn't going to happen. He still holds the CBJ team record for highest +/- in a season by a forward. This is from a guy who had 40 goals in the OHL and represented Canada in the WJC. Other guys talk about sacrificing for the good of the team; MacKenzie has done exactly that.

4) Florida has no other worthy player in such a position. Aaron Ekblad may be playing like an All-Star; he's 18 and will have a ton more chances. Ditto Nick Bjugstad. Roberto Luongo has been there many times already.

Let MacKenzie have his moment. When the aforementioned Stu Grimson was sent to the Skills Competition, he commented about how he never thought that a plumber would be invited to the grand ball. When Dale Hunter was told that he was named to the 1997 Eastern All-Star Team as a Commissioner's Choice, he burst into tears. (That's right: Dale Hunter possessed emotions outside of hatred)

5) MacKenzie is still popular in Columbus. A guy with barely 300 career games, less than 50 career goals, and less than 100 career points is universally respected and loved in the city that gave him his first best chance.

6) No, this isn't Rory Fitzpatrick. MacKenzie's career high in goals is 9 (twice); Fitzpatrick had 10 in his career. MacKenzie was +19 with Columbus; Fitzpatrick is a career - player. MacKenzie has more than double the points of Fitzpatrick, and the gap widens when you consider that nearly half of Fitzpatrick's career came after his all-star push.

7) I'm not attempting to embarrass the NHL, or change the voting process, or make some type of grandiose statement. I believe that Derek MacKenzie should be the Florida Panthers' representative in the 2015 All-Star Game, to be held in the very city that MacKenzie had his best years and emerged as an NHL player instead of a career minor leaguer.

He's earned the chance.

(Note: I do not endorse or support bot voting, scripts, or other attempts to manipulate the legitimate process.)
 

db2011

Registered User
Oct 10, 2011
3,565
474
Brooklyn
Going through the rest of the league, there's only one logical person to stuff the ballot box for: Derek MacKenzie. Here's why.

1) I'm a longtime proponent of the Commissioner's Choice selections that existed during the 1990s. These served as a way to put players into the game who may have been overlooked or were at the end of the line and unlikely to make it in otherwise. Picks included HOFers at the end of long careers (Bryan Trottier, Larry Robinson, Mark Messier), players who were generally underrated during their careers and approaching the end (Dale Hunter, Tony Granato), and players whose value to their teams eluded the stats sheet (Brad Marsh, Craig MacTavish).

2) The NHL used to have miscellaneous players in the skills competition, giving them a chance to showcase their skills against the best in the world. Who could forget guys like Stu Grimson and Jon Rohloff rubbing elbows with Wayne Gretzky and Ray Bourque?

MacKenzie would simply be a continuation of these established traditions.

3) We'd be hypocrites to not vote for someone like MacKenzie. The media lauds team-first players who will do "whatever it takes". We all eat up the idea of the quiet player who will do anything to help his team win, whether killing penalties or sacrificing his offensive opportunities to play shutdown defense. We point to these players and say "That is what hockey is all about." Yet when All-Star time comes, we all vote for the superlatively skilled players and shove aside the quiet ones whose game escapes the spotlight.

MacKenzie, in many ways, is the very type of player who should be lauded. He was a 5th-round pick of the Atlanta Thrashers, who were so poorly managed that they could read through a stack of Superman comic books and never figure out the connection to Clark Kent. After years of being shuttled between the NHL and the AHL, including captaining the Chicago Wolves to the Calder Cup Finals, he wasn't qualified and was picked up by Columbus. He spent 7 years in Columbus, anchoring the fourth line and doing everything that was demanded of him. Fill in on a higher line for an injured player? Get MacKenzie out there. Need a defensive zone faceoff with 30 seconds left against a 6-on-4? MacKenzie, take the draw.

His career was almost ended twice, once due to a severely broken ankle and once due to a severe concussion. He persevered, knowing that being a first-line player in the NHL wasn't going to happen. He still holds the CBJ team record for highest +/- in a season by a forward. This is from a guy who had 40 goals in the OHL and represented Canada in the WJC. Other guys talk about sacrificing for the good of the team; MacKenzie has done exactly that.

4) Florida has no other worthy player in such a position. Aaron Ekblad may be playing like an All-Star; he's 18 and will have a ton more chances. Ditto Nick Bjugstad. Roberto Luongo has been there many times already.

Let MacKenzie have his moment. When the aforementioned Stu Grimson was sent to the Skills Competition, he commented about how he never thought that a plumber would be invited to the grand ball. When Dale Hunter was told that he was named to the 1997 Eastern All-Star Team as a Commissioner's Choice, he burst into tears. (That's right: Dale Hunter possessed emotions outside of hatred)

5) MacKenzie is still popular in Columbus. A guy with barely 300 career games, less than 50 career goals, and less than 100 career points is universally respected and loved in the city that gave him his first best chance.

6) No, this isn't Rory Fitzpatrick. MacKenzie's career high in goals is 9 (twice); Fitzpatrick had 10 in his career. MacKenzie was +19 with Columbus; Fitzpatrick is a career - player. MacKenzie has more than double the points of Fitzpatrick, and the gap widens when you consider that nearly half of Fitzpatrick's career came after his all-star push.

7) I'm not attempting to embarrass the NHL, or change the voting process, or make some type of grandiose statement. I believe that Derek MacKenzie should be the Florida Panthers' representative in the 2015 All-Star Game, to be held in the very city that MacKenzie had his best years and emerged as an NHL player instead of a career minor leaguer.

He's earned the chance.

(Note: I do not endorse or support bot voting, scripts, or other attempts to manipulate the legitimate process.)

No arguments here; a compelling and persuasive case.
 

EspenK

Registered User
Sep 25, 2011
15,619
4,186
I voted Nash-Crosby-Voracek (just couldn't vote for Carter or Gabby :sarcasm:)

Giordano-Weber

Quick

Would have voted Forsberg but couldn't find him on the ballot
 

cbjfan4life

Registered User
Aug 2, 2005
462
0
ouch........and actually.....vote in Mason since he gives up weak ones like its an all star game anyways
 

1857 Howitzer

******* Linesman
Aug 27, 2007
5,715
193
Ohio
It's disappointing to me how far down the leaderboards Johansen and Foligno are, they're both playing ABOVE PPG right now and you got guys like Alex Galchenyuk (13 points in 21 games) above them :shakehead

It's a popularity contest really. With so few spots it's not very likely a Jacket will get voted in.
 

Samkow

Now do Classical Gas
Jul 4, 2002
16,354
488
Detroit
It sounds like the neon dream will be coming true.

http://www.thehockeynews.com/blog/leaked-images-show-neon-all-star-jerseys-could-be-on-the-horizon/

ASG-Jerseys.jpg
 

slacketbacker

Registered User
Oct 25, 2005
33
1
USA

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad