Do bad hockey player win scoring titles? Iginla was a very consistent player and racked up awards. While playing with Heatley and Spezza alfredsson did not.
We're not comparing Jody Hull to Brett Hull here.
If you call following up 90 point full seasons with 65 point full seasons "consistent", sure Iginla was "consistent".
How and under what circumstances did he win those awards? Did he deserve all of them?
In 2006, Alfredsson was 4th in the league in scoring and 3rd in PPG.
In 2007, they didn't play together nearly as much as you think. Alfredsson had significant amounts of points with 3 different lines. Think of this season more like Fisher & Schaefer at ES, Spezza & Heatley on the PP.
In 2008, Alfredsson was leading the league in scoring at the All Star Break before getting a knee injury and a concussion. He finished 4th in PPG.
In 2009, Craig Hartsburg was a terrible coach that sabotaged the team's offense so that our team could get stuck in the defensive zone and our goalies pelted with shots. Alfredsson probably could have produced more points on a line with Fisher & Schaefer... but with an NHL calibre coach.