- Sep 28, 2014
- 76,849
- 123,501
...Holy ****! I forgot Giroux ! Seriously!
4.GIROUX
5.Recchi
6.Richards...Honestly...a huge oversight!
...Holy ****! I forgot Giroux ! Seriously!
4.GIROUX
5.Recchi
6.Richards...Honestly...a huge oversight!
Judging by the responses, Eric Desjardins will be highly underrated here. I gave him a pity vote here, but #2 should be between him and Giroux, IMO.
I keep picturing Boxcar going over the list repeatably looking for Manning!
My thoughts as well re: Desjardins. I think a lot of people remember the decent-but-not-great version of him from 2002-2004 and forget how amazing he was in the 90's. He was in the tier right behind the HoF / Norris winners of those years like Leetch, Blake, and MacInnis.Judging by the responses, Eric Desjardins will be highly underrated here. I gave him a pity vote here, but #2 should be between him and Giroux, IMO.
1.Lindros
2.Brind'Amour
3.LeClair
4.Recchi
5.Richards...My thoughts!
You didnt ask me but since I did the same (Leclair), I'll trow in my $0.02.
My preference here is based on the level of reliability - Lindros's injury history and the drama with him and his parents I feel he was a distraction. It brought down my perception of his value. No doubt the greatest potential and best talent on the list, but ...
Judging by the responses, Eric Desjardins will be highly underrated here. I gave him a pity vote here, but #2 should be between him and Giroux, IMO.
I would put Brind'Amour ahead of Giroux. He was the better player. Mark Howe is still ahead of Desjardins as well.
God, really?Willams should be on the list, but because blockhead BOB Clarke made the worst trade in Flyers history he isn't. Maybe we can add Danny Markov instead.
I would put Brind'Amour ahead of Giroux. He was the better player. Mark Howe is still ahead of Desjardins as well.
I would put Brind'Amour ahead of Giroux. He was the better player. Mark Howe is still ahead of Desjardins as well.
How many top 10 point finishes or Hart votes for Brindy? 0.
Wasn't Howe retired by the time we're discussing players?