McGarnagle
Yes.
- Aug 5, 2017
- 28,906
- 38,595
Yanks are going all-in on Judge and if he does choose the Giants it'll be fascinating to see how Cashman pivots.Likewise, agree here; I don't see NYY playing with any top shortstop. If they're not keeping their homegrown superstar I expect them to do a short-term, high AAV deal with DeGrom or Verlander. They've seemed perfectly content to roll with kids in their middle infield and I don't see Cashman panicking unless Steinbrenner threatens to fire him unless he gets a big name SS.
They don't really need a shortstop because Volpe will be up by mid-season at latest (and I don't think they're going to screw with his development switching him to 2B or 3B). I see them chasing Bellinger (I think they do that even if Judge is in the fold) or perhaps giving Brantley a 1 or 2 year high money deal to bridge the gap. Because other than the unknown entity that is Yoshida, there are no outfielders on the market beyond Judge who will move the Yankees' needle one bit. I could see them bringing on Belt or Bell as a DH to get some power back in the lineup, but the more I look at it, they're not going to be able to replace Judge.
I kind of see them the same way the Bruins looked all offseason where if Bergeron retired it was a bridge year to reset the cap and not compete, but if he committed to coming back it's time to load up and run it back for a shot at the championship. If the Yanks resign Judge, they're going all in, probably winning the division again, and will be competing with the Astros again for the pennant. If Judge leaves, they could be fine and could get a WC spot, but they might just want to reset their luxury tax number and wait for next year to start building up again.