- Dec 20, 2018
- 21,826
- 47,175
Clarke makes far better reads than Power and Hughes to my eyes. That's enough to mitigate the skating woes, which are very overblown.
I don’t think they really have been punished tho when you think about the other rules that have been implemented.
I’m not sure but their average pick might’ve actually gone up. I’d rather have a bit worse odds for #1 overall but not be able to fall any further than 3 than have a bit better odds but possibly be able to fall to 4. I’m sure Detroit would’ve preferred this last year.
Edit: If these odds are for future years too the odds for the top teams will naturally go back up a bit anyways with the addition of the rules where teams can’t go up more than 10 spots. I’m not sure the odds will be the same next year tho.
The changes, approved by League’s Board of Governors, will reduce the likelihood of the worst-finishing Club dropping in the Draft Order and not retaining the right to the First Overall Selection; reduce the magnitude of any possible drop in DraftOrder for the worst-finishing Club
I don’t know, I think it was more about the bottom team not being able to fall as much as they could in previous years. I like it better like this. They aren’t as likely to get first overall but they also can’t fall as much.The NHL said this about rule changes:
I assumed that meant the odds for the bottom three teams would improve and not worsen. It’s a little weird that they drop so much but I guess Seattle’s ~10% had to come from somewhere and 43.5% of the odds were in the top 3.
I’m also assuming the odds will likely change next season. (Who knows, just an assumption.)
NHL.com Media Site
One thing that I haven't seen mentioned - Buffalo will be picking ahead of us unless we are drafting 1st or 2nd overall so that's one team that won't be taking one of the top defenseman as I'd have to assume they go Beniers. Anaheim will likely take Powers if he is on the board however if he is not I think they will take Hughes or Edvinsson. Seattle - i have zero clue which direction they would go.
Yusaku Ando at eliteprospects.com
Thoughts on him in the later rounds? I’m a sucker for Japan. @StevenToddIves
tbf, skating for a defenseman is pretty important. It's not something you can just ignore.
All I ask is if they go with Luke, they did it because they think he will be the better player and not because he's Jack's brother. I don't want this organization to become an even bigger joke than it already has been the past few years. We'll never really know why they picked Luke if they do though.
While hes not a poor skater, Id argue skating is Clarke's biggest deficiency in his game. Though that could be his transitional defense, which Im also not fond of.Brandt Clarke is a good skater, and he's also the brother of a Devils player.
I watched Ando a little, but don't consider him a prospect for the first 6 rounds, so I drew my attention elsewhere. Ando is tiny -- 5'7-145 -- and a perimeter player who is a bit of a liability outside the offensive zone. Although he certainly has some high-end offensive skills, his surrounding limitations have inhibited him statistically -- just 8 goals in the USHL this year over 45 games.
Ando is not a player I would draft, but certainly the type of player I would invite to training camp if he went undrafted.
I am too. But I really doubt he gets drafted this year. If he explodes more next year..then maybe someone might draft him as an overrager at most.
Still, im rooting for him to get drafted though!
His transitional defence!?!While hes not a poor skater, Id argue skating is Clarke's biggest deficiency in his game. Though that could be his transitional defense, which Im also not fond of.
past that though I dont see many holes
it would be kawaii if he made it :3
Perhaps I should have been more specificHis transitional defence!?!
He’s one the best defenders I’ve seen in transition. Literally one of my favourite things about him. Really good backwards skater who keeps perfect gaps and doesn’t get beat. He did great at that in the U18s and every where else I’ve seen him.
I have more of a problem with his defence below the hash marks as he sometimes gets outmuscled or loses positioning on a guy down low or in front of the net.
Okay I think I get what you’re saying. If the puck gets chipped in behind him or a guys blowing wide around him he’s not the quickest on his pivot or first couple strides. That’s a fair assessment and I agree that it’s similar to smithPerhaps I should have been more specific
I find his first step and his pivot To be slow, and is likely due to his awkward stride. Ty Smith has this exact same issue I find
Why tf did the rangers odds double?My god, what you’re suggestion would set off an existential crisis. (Does the Arizona pick exist? If it’s in the lottery does that mean it must exist at some point in this process? If so when is it forfeited? It they’re in the draft lottery and win the lottery are they then forfeiting the pick or the pick AND the lottery win?... *heads explode*)
I assume an Arizona rep doesn’t have to go the lottery and potentially watch their team potentially not win the lottery via a win of the lottery.
Someone broke down the biggest losers and winner of the odd tweaks so you don’t have to:
Winners: Ottawa, Vancouver, Devils
Losers: Buffalo, Anaheim, Seattle
View attachment 435990
Id say Ty has more of a knack for seeing offensive rotations and chances for deep pucks/shots on net, so perhaps a reactionary mindset and vision edit 2: more a systematic mindsetI think people were already talking about it and someone didn’t agree with it but I see a lot of similarities between Clarke and Smith.
Both very smooth skaters with good edges that just aren’t the quickest. They’re both very smart puck movers too, have good patience and know how to slow things down.
There’s obviously some differences too and Clarke is better at Smith in some regards which is why he has more potential. Clarke is bigger and can bring more physicality, has slightly better hands and puck skills, has a better shot and a bit more offensive creativity.
Ty is really good in the offensive zone, moves well, makes smart plays and creates offense. I just think that Clarke has that extra bit of vision and skill where he’s able to make a play that no one else saw or expected.
You gotta look past the first pick.Why tf did the rangers odds double?
I would be pissed if I was Buffalo or Anaheim
I am actually pleased because it looks like we are sharing the third place odds with Seattle. Before it was Seattle at 11.5 and nj at 9.5 now we are both at 10.5