2018 Rate My Team Thread

[sa cyred]

So... I'm an idiot. I panicked in round 6, and I picked a QB in a 10 team re-draft. I basically ran out of time. I picked 7th. It is a PPR league.

QB- Newton (round 6)
RB- Kamara (round 1)
RB- Mixon (round 3)
WR- Allen (round 2)
WR- Hilton (round 4)
WR- Landry (round 5)
TE- Reed (round 11)
Flex- R. Freeman (round 7)
Flex- Funchess (round 8)
K- Forbath (round 18)
DEF- New Orleans (round 16)

BN- Ryan (round 15)
BN- Carson (round 10)
BN- C. Thompson (round 12)
BN- Wilkins (round 14)
BN- Riddick (round 17)
BN- Fuller (round 9)
BN- A. Miller (round 13)

Solid draft. I do agree that in PPR QBs later is more important but you picks some good players rest of draft. Only guy I am not a fan of is Mixon who I think, while he should do well, has some high bust potential.

12 team Pick 8 (Linear/Non-snaking) 0.5 PPR (2-4 Keeper league)

QB: Newton
WR: Diggs
WR: Landry
RB: Kamara (Keeper)
W/R/T: Mixon (Keeper)
W/R/T: Royce Freeman
TE: Doyle
K: Vinatieri
D: CJ Mosley
DB: Jamal Adams

Bench:

Watkins
Crowder
Michel
Tevin Coleman
Bernard
Barber

Solid for a 8 team league.

8 team PPR had the 8th pick.

QB - Brees, Garappolo
RB - Fournette, McCaffrey, Crowell, Cohen, Montgomery
WR - Thielen, Cooper, M. Jones, Goodwin, Benjamin, Edelman
TE - Kelce, Randolph
K - Lutz
D- Rams

I think you also had a good draft. I worry about McCaffrey abit with Anderson being there. Having Edelman is solid. Will be dominate like usual once he is back. Who did you take with the 1st overall pick? I am guessing Fournette?

 

[sa cyred]

My draft: this is PPR, 10 man league. I had the 4th pick.

1 QB: Cousins (11th)
2 RBs: David Johnson (1st), Gordon (2nd)
2 WRs: Baldwin (4th), Cooper (5th)
1 TE: Gronk (3rd)
1 Flex: Ju-Ju (6th)
D: Chargers (14th)
K: Bryant (15th)

Bench:
Rivers (13th)
Royce Freeman (7th)
Watkins (8th)
Cobb (9th)
Crowder (10th)
James White (12th)
O.J. Howard (16th)

Overall alittle worries with my receivers. I think I’m pretty good elsewhere though

 

[HoseEmDown]

Solid draft. I do agree that in PPR QBs later is more important but you picks some good players rest of draft. Only guy I am not a fan of is Mixon who I think, while he should do well, has some high bust potential.

Solid for a 8 team league.


I think you also had a good draft. I worry about McCaffrey abit with Anderson being there. Having Edelman is solid. Will be dominate like usual once he is back. Who did you take with the 1st overall pick? I am guessing Fournette?

I went Fournette at 8 and McCaffrey at 9. Was a bit of a stretch on Fournette that early but wanted to get my RB out of the way early as there wasn't gonna be much left at 24 and 25. McCaffrey I only picked because of the ppr aspect. Thinking he's going to be the top pass catching RB so liking those extra points. Plus WR is deep as I didn't pick my first one till I took Cooper in the 4th round.

 

[rangerssharks414]

12 team Pick 8 (Linear/Non-snaking) 0.5 PPR (2-4 Keeper league)

QB: Newton
WR: Diggs
WR: Landry
RB: Kamara (Keeper)
W/R/T: Mixon (Keeper)
W/R/T: Royce Freeman
TE: Doyle
K: Vinatieri
D: CJ Mosley
DB: Jamal Adams

Bench:

Watkins
Crowder
Michel
Tevin Coleman
Bernard
Barber

This looks really solid for a 12 teamer. I think Crowder will end up being a steal this year. What happened if you didn't keep the maximum amount of players?

8 team PPR had the 8th pick.

QB - Brees, Garappolo
RB - Fournette, McCaffrey, Crowell, Cohen, Montgomery
WR - Thielen, Cooper, M. Jones, Goodwin, Benjamin, Edelman
TE - Kelce, Randolph
K - Lutz
D- Rams

It's hard for me to judge 8 team leagues since I don't play in them. I would think that you could have gotten a better RB3 than Crowell. I don't think drafting a backup QB is worth it either.

 

[rangerssharks414]

My draft: this is PPR, 10 man league. I had the 4th pick.

1 QB: Cousins (11th)
2 RBs: David Johnson (1st), Gordon (2nd)
2 WRs: Baldwin (4th), Cooper (5th)
1 TE: Gronk (3rd)
1 Flex: Ju-Ju (6th)
D: Chargers (14th)
K: Bryant (15th)

Bench:
Rivers (13th)
Royce Freeman (7th)
Watkins (8th)
Cobb (9th)
Crowder (10th)
James White (12th)
O.J. Howard (16th)

Overall alittle worries with my receivers. I think I’m pretty good elsewhere though

Yeah, I'm not fond of your WRs at all. Cobb seems like a huge reach there. As mentioned, I love Crowder this year. Getting Gordon 17th overall in a PPR is really good. I probably would have taken a receiver where you took Gronk. White is a good pick that late as well. I have no idea why he's so undervalued.

 

[sa cyred]

Yeah, I'm not fond of your WRs at all. Cobb seems like a huge reach there. As mentioned, I love Crowder this year. Getting Gordon 17th overall in a PPR is really good. I probably would have taken a receiver where you took Gronk. White is a good pick that late as well. I have no idea why he's so undervalued.

Yea, in the 3rd I had Devante Adams and he was grabbed last minute right before my pick. Value wise the next best WR was Larry Fitzgerald which I didn’t know had more value then Baldwin.

There was abit if a WR run so Cobb was one of the “Aaron Rodgers” pick. I think JuJu can possibly provide WR2 value and Freeman should be the starter in Den. But yea WR not very strong

 

[HoseEmDown]

This looks really solid for a 12 teamer. I think Crowder will end up being a steal this year. What happened if you didn't keep the maximum amount of players?



It's hard for me to judge 8 team leagues since I don't play in them. I would think that you could have gotten a better RB3 than Crowell. I don't think drafting a backup QB is worth it either.

I didn't pick Crowell till the 8th round. The next RB picked were Mark Ingram, Dion Lewis, Kerryon Johnson and Duke Johnson. By the time I picked my 3rd RB the pickings were slim. As for the QB pick it was the last pick of the draft. I already had a bunch of backups in other positions and if Jimmy G really breaks out he might be a good trade piece later.

 

[m9]

My draft: this is PPR, 10 man league. I had the 4th pick.

1 QB: Cousins (11th)
2 RBs: David Johnson (1st), Gordon (2nd)
2 WRs: Baldwin (4th), Cooper (5th)
1 TE: Gronk (3rd)
1 Flex: Ju-Ju (6th)
D: Chargers (14th)
K: Bryant (15th)

Bench:
Rivers (13th)
Royce Freeman (7th)
Watkins (8th)
Cobb (9th)
Crowder (10th)
James White (12th)
O.J. Howard (16th)

Overall alittle worries with my receivers. I think I’m pretty good elsewhere though

Aside from Cobb, I like this team. This is very similar to how I would be drafting teams this season.

 

[Evincar]

This looks really solid for a 12 teamer. I think Crowder will end up being a steal this year. What happened if you didn't keep the maximum amount of players?

I would just end up with 2 early picks. Keeper are slotted in rounds 1-4. So if kept only 2 I pick in round 3, if kept 4 I pick in round 5, unless I traded away/acquired picks etc.

 

[Club]

Had the 8th pick. 10 teams.

QB - Deshaun Watson
WR - Stefon Diggs
WR - Jarvis Landry
RB - Alvin Kamara
RB - Melvin Gordon
TE - Greg Olsen

W/R/T - Marshawn Lynch

BN - Alshon Jeffery
BN - Devin Funchess
BN - Nick Chubb
BN - Chris Thompson
BN - Randall Cobb
BN - Ty Montgomery
BN - Mitch Trubisky
BN - Marqise Lee

K - Robbie Gould
DEF - Patriots

Edit: trying to trade for another TE since Olsen is injury prone

 

[BondraTime]

6th pick 12 team PPR

QB- Newton
RB - McCoy
RB- L. Miller
WR - Brown
WR - Green
Flex - M. Jones
TE - Njoku

BN- Ingram
BN- J. White
BN- Bernard
BN- Riddick
BN- Crabtree
BN - Woods

 

[rangerssharks414]

Had the 8th pick. 10 teams.

QB - Deshaun Watson
WR - Stefon Diggs
WR - Jarvis Landry
RB - Alvin Kamara
RB - Melvin Gordon
TE - Greg Olsen

W/R/T - Marshawn Lynch

BN - Alshon Jeffery
BN - Devin Funchess
BN - Nick Chubb
BN - Chris Thompson
BN - Randall Cobb
BN - Ty Montgomery
BN - Mitch Trubisky
BN - Marqise Lee

K - Robbie Gould
DEF - Patriots

Edit: trying to trade for another TE since Olsen is injury prone

You're golden if this is a PPR. I'm not really a fan of taking a QB early in a 10 team league that starts only one QB (even though I did it once this year already because I panicked). Jeffery is a good stash if he misses time. I don't like Cobb and Chubb. I bet you could have gotten a better backup QB than Trubisky. It looks solid, though.

6th pick 12 team PPR

QB- Newton
RB - McCoy
RB- L. Miller
WR - Brown
WR - Green
Flex - M. Jones
TE - Njoku

BN- Ingram
BN- J. White
BN- Bernard
BN- Riddick
BN- Crabtree
BN - Woods

Miller is a great value pick this year. So is McCoy. I like your bench receivers. Riddick and White are good for PPR as well.

 

[OilerPensfan97]

Deep 12 team .5 PPR/7th pick:

QB-Deshaun Watson
QB-Matt Ryan
WR-Odell Beckham Jr.
WR-Chris Hogan
WR-Robert Woods
WR-Kenny Golladay
RB-Jerick McKinnon (acquired in trade; initially drafted Joe Mixon)
RB-Kenyan Drake
TE-Kyle Rudolph
TE-Benjamin Watson
FLEX-Tevin Coleman
K-Justin Tucker
K-Josh Lambo
DEF-Philadelphia
DEF-Washington
IDP-Telvin Smith
IDP-Blake Martinez
IDP-Kwon Alexander
IDP-Mark Barron
BENCH-Sam Darnold (QB)
BENCH-Josh Doctson (WR)
BENCH-Theo Riddick (RB)
BENCH-Latavius Murray (RB)
BENCH-Jesse James (TE)
BENCH-Brandon Marshall (WR)
BENCH-Adrian Peterson (RB)
BENCH-Jonathon Williams (RB) (aquired in trade with Jerick McKinnon for Joe Mixon)
BENCH-Jason Sanders (K)
BENCH-Dallas (DEF)
BENCH-Roquan Smith (IDP)

 

[tacogeoff]

10 team standard live draft hsd 5th overall. Got a little drunk by round six we started with a shot after every pick until the bottle was gone lol

Qbs. 6.Wentz 14.Dak

Rbs. 1.Elliot 2.cook 7.coleman 10.chubb 15.carson

Wrs 4. a.cooper 5. juju. 9.Josh gordon and 13.kirk

Te 3.kelce and 12.hooper

Def 8.vikings

K. 11. Lutz

 

[rangerssharks414]

Deep 12 team .5 PPR/7th pick:

QB-Deshaun Watson
QB-Matt Ryan
WR-Odell Beckham Jr.
WR-Chris Hogan
WR-Robert Woods
WR-Kenny Golladay
RB-Jerick McKinnon (acquired in trade; initially drafted Joe Mixon)
RB-Kenyan Drake
TE-Kyle Rudolph
TE-Benjamin Watson
FLEX-Tevin Coleman
K-Justin Tucker
K-Josh Lambo
DEF-Philadelphia
DEF-Washington
IDP-Telvin Smith
IDP-Blake Martinez
IDP-Kwon Alexander
IDP-Mark Barron
BENCH-Sam Darnold (QB)
BENCH-Josh Doctson (WR)
BENCH-Theo Riddick (RB)
BENCH-Latavius Murray (RB)
BENCH-Jesse James (TE)
BENCH-Brandon Marshall (WR)
BENCH-Adrian Peterson (RB)
BENCH-Jonathon Williams (RB) (aquired in trade with Jerick McKinnon for Joe Mixon)
BENCH-Jason Sanders (K)
BENCH-Dallas (DEF)
BENCH-Roquan Smith (IDP)

I would have liked to see better running backs, but in a two QB league, you probably had to take the QBs early. I like Golladay this year. If the Dolphins do the right thing (which I'm convinced that they won't), they'll make Drake their bellcow. It looks good, though.

10 team standard live draft hsd 5th overall. Got a little drunk by round six we started with a shot after every pick until the bottle was gone lol

Qbs. 6.Wentz 14.Dak

Rbs. 1.Elliot 2.cook 7.coleman 10.chubb 15.carson

Wrs 4. a.cooper 5. juju. 9.Josh gordon and 13.kirk

Te 3.kelce and 12.hooper

Def 8.vikings

K. 11. Lutz

I don't see a need for a backup QB in a 10 team league unless there's a really good value pick left. I don't think Dak in the 14th round is that guy. Your receivers aren't good for a 10 team league. Carson in the 15th looks like a steal. You took a defense way too early. The same goes for the kicker. I don't like this team. Sorry.

 

[rangerssharks414]

I just finished my final (as far as I know) one year draft of the year (the rest of my leagues are dynasties).

10 team PPR (6th pick)

QB- Stafford (round 11)
RB- Kamara (round 1)
RB- L. Miller (round 5)
WR- Allen (round 2)
WR- Diggs (round 3)
WR- Fitzgerald (round 4)
TE- Njoku (round 12)
Flex- Burkhead (round 6)
Flex- Crowder (round 7)
K- Boswell (round 18)
DEF- Baltimore (round 16)

BN- T. Coleman (round 9)
BN- Ja. Williams (round 10)
BN- Peterson (round 13)
BN- R. Anderson (round 8)
BN- Godwin (round 14)
BN- Cole (round 15)
BN- J. White (round 17)

 

[mouser]

11th pick in a 12 team TD-ONLY league where QB TD's count for 6 points (instead of the common 4 points).

1(11) RB Kareem Hunt
2(14) RB Melvin Gordon
3(35) WR Juju Smith-Schuster
4(38) TE Jimmy Graham
5(59) QB Jared Goff
6(62) WR Nelson Agholor
7(83) QB Carson Wentz
8(86) RB Kenyan Drake
9(107) WR Robert Woods
10(110) WR Tyrell Williams
11(131) K Justin Tucker
12(134) RB Austin Ekeler
13(155) WR John Brown
14(158) RB Chris Warren
15(179) TE Hayden Hurst

Position(start)
QB(1): Goff, Wentz
RB(2): Hunt, Gordon, Drake, Ekeler, Warren
WR(3): Smith-Schuster, Agholor, Woods, T Williams, John Brown
TE(1): Graham, Hurst
K(1): Tucker
D(1): will pick up one on FA and platoon each week since our D's don't score much

Was an interesting draft. Wanted to sleep a little longer on QB's but the guy drafting 12th (snake draft so double picks for him) didn't have a QB yet when rounds 5 & 7 rolled around and the options were getting thin, so elected to take Goff and Wentz a little earlier then I would have otherwise preferred. QB's are more valuable in this scoring format then most leagues due to the 6 points/TD--3 QB's went in the 1st, and 2 more in the 2nd, ten QB's were already gone by the time I took Goff. Picked up a couple boom or bust types towards the end in Warren and Hurst, plus one of the better handcuff backs in Ekeler.

Choice in the 1st round was between Hunt and Kamara. I took Kamara in the 15th round last season and just didn't feel right using a 1st on him this year, so Hunt it was. WR feels a little thin, but having Jimmy Graham could easily make up for that if he pans out with a top 10 WR/TE season.

 

[Zibanejbread]

Drafted 2/4 teams so far.

10 team, PPR, picked 8th... yes, I reached for Gordon at 8 because I feel that strongly about him this year:
QB: Rivers
RB: Gordon
RB: L Miller
WR: M Thomas
WR: TY Hilton
TE: Burton
W/R/T: Diggs
BN: M Ingram, J Crowder, R Cobb, M Lynch, P Barber, G Bernard, M Sanu, B Powell
Will need to drop 2 bench players for K and D/ST

12 team, PPR, also .5 points per carry, picked 1st:
QB: Wilson
RB: Gurley
RB: D Lewis
WR: D Adams
WR: AJ Green
TE: Engram
W/R/T: Baldwin
K: M Crosby
D/ST: Lions (play NYJ week 1)
BN: P Barber, J Crowder, Marvin Jones, B Powell, R Anderson, A Ekeler, C Ivory, A Smith

 

[Evincar]

Edit: trying to trade for another TE since Olsen is injury prone

He missed 2 games in his first 10 seasons before getting hurt last season. Thats pretty much the definition of durable.

 

[PALE PWNR]

13 Team Auction Draft, Keep up to 2 players per year for a maximum of 3 years.
Scoring format: PPR, 6 points for thrown TD's rather than 4, All-Play (H2H scoring vs every team every week)

$225 per team

QB: Carson Wentz ($9), Andy Dalton ($1)
RB: LeVeon Bell ($71), Leonard Fournette ($59), Ronald Jones II ($13), LeGarrette Blount ($2)
WR: Davante Adams ($40), Nelson Agholor ($10), DeSean Jackson ($1), Chris Godwin ($3), Josh Doctson ($3)
TE: Evan Engram ($8), Mike Gesicki ($1)
PK: Chris Boswell ($1)
TD: Tennessee Titans ($1)

 

[Club]

He missed 2 games in his first 10 seasons before getting hurt last season. Thats pretty much the definition of durable.

Oh I wasn't sure. I don't follow the nfl as much. Thanks!

 

[tacogeoff]

I would have liked to see better running backs, but in a two QB league, you probably had to take the QBs early. I like Golladay this year. If the Dolphins do the right thing (which I'm convinced that they won't), they'll make Drake their bellcow. It looks good, though.



I don't see a need for a backup QB in a 10 team league unless there's a really good value pick left. I don't think Dak in the 14th round is that guy. Your receivers aren't good for a 10 team league. Carson in the 15th looks like a steal. You took a defense way too early. The same goes for the kicker. I don't like this team. Sorry.

Lol ya my receivers are going to be boom or bust. In the 3rd round most of the monsters were gone so i went with kelce to hopefully supplement my wrs and have a top te. Qbs started going early after one person pulled the trigger on rodgers. Took dak bc wentz isnt a sure thing for week 1. My rbs i feel are great. Took defence early as i enjoy having a solid D and usually have bad luck if im streaming.there wasnt alot of players available that would make a significant difference (100+ pts) behind my starters.

Not over the moon with it but i will be ok.

2 more drafts to go

 

[Falco Lombardi]

10 team, half point PPR draft. I had the 9th pick.

QB: Aaron Rodgers
RB: Leonard Fournette
RB: Dalvin Cook
WR: Devante Adams
WR: Allen Robinson
TE: Trey Burton
FLEX: Dion Lewis
D/ST: Minnesota
K: Josh Lambo

BN: Kerryon Johnson
BN: Alshon Jeffery
BN: Jamison Crowder
BN: Dede Westbrook
BN: Kenny Stills
BN: Nick Chubb

Worried a bit about the WRs so I loaded up on more. Thoughts?

 

[Evincar]

10 team, half point PPR draft. I had the 9th pick.

QB: Aaron Rodgers
RB: Leonard Fournette
RB: Dalvin Cook
WR: Devante Adams
WR: Allen Robinson
TE: Trey Burton
FLEX: Dion Lewis
D/ST: Minnesota
K: Josh Lambo

BN: Kerryon Johnson
BN: Alshon Jeffery
BN: Jamison Crowder
BN: Dede Westbrook
BN: Kenny Stills
BN: Nick Chubb

Worried a bit about the WRs so I loaded up on more. Thoughts?

I think your WRs are fine. Not great but nothing to be worried about, you have good depth. I probably would have made sure to cuff Cook with Murray. Very solid team.

 

[spintheblackcircle]

12 team league with a flex PPR picked 12th

Watson
Dalton

McCaffrey
Freeman
Drake
Gore
Barber

Landry
D Thomas
Cole
Ross
Sanu

Doyle
Hooper

Gould

Chargers