I think back in juniors Staal was pretty decent at moving the puck with his skating but his best work was always positioning, stick work, controlling the neutral zone or making plays in his own end, but could move things out decently well when needed. The NHL is another level though and I think he's gone through some ankle injuries over the years
e: The thing I like about taking a shot at a "risky and raw" pick like Miller is that from all accounts he is a hard worker and a smart person. If you have a lot to learn about a position and a lot to improve on to match your physical gifts, having the smarts and dedication to work on it will give you a better chance at reaching your potential. Some guys have great gifts but rely on them too much. Miller sounds like a guy who will do what it takes to improve on his weaknesses
Yeah, and I think many of us was questioning when not if Staal would take that final step and start contributing more offensively. Staal was also at his peak a clear No 1 D on a team that made the POs.
But somewhere along the line I have always felt that Staal changed completely and became a player that just played to get by, and stopped going to war out there, stopped dreaming of doing great things and so forth. Eric’s hit and that shot to the face just got to him.
Lev- I haven’t followed the conversation, but on the mobile part: The league was pretty immobile when Staal was a rookie. Rich Pilon, Excelby, White, Sutton, the Hatchers and a bunch of other guys like that still played.
Nobody would think about callin Staal a mobile D if he was 18 today, but like back in what 06’, compared to some he was definitely very mobile...
Edit: Reading more of the thread and grasping the context — I don’t think it’s dumb to compare Miller to Staal. But like I said, the game was very different 12 years ago. But taking that into mind I think we all would — love it — if Miller can copy Staals development path the first 5-6 years. Becoming a No 1 D on his team and leading it to the POs. But I don’t think it makes sense to claim that Miller will look in the NHL in 2020 like an 20 y/o Staal who went into a time machine in 2006 would look in 2020. If you get what I mean.