Prospect Info: 2015 Ranking #2

[henchman21]

here are the 2004 NOMINEES
Trent Hunter, New York Islanders
Andrew Raycroft, Boston Bruins
Michael Ryder, Montreal Canadiens

that was a bad year

Bad year or not Raycroft had a 2.05 GAA and a .926 sv percentage while looking great in the playoffs. Far, far more than Picks has accomplished so far.

hischon havent proven that he can play in NHL. he was given the chanse but didnt take it. you can say that 16 games is a small sample for pickard but he was our starter then and put upp great numbers.

But Picks has had some issues in the AHL... this past season was the first where he looked like he has a grasp on the starting job in the AHL. And even then, there was some inconsistency in his game. Don't get me wrong, I think Picks is a solid prospect, but his 16 games isn't indicative of the level of prospect that he is. There is a much larger body of work out there on him and it all needs to be taken into account.

 

[RockLobster]

Bigras of course, same deal as before if we get 100 votes I'll put the new poll up.

I'd add Wood here too.

100 votes?

Man, Bigras is stomping the rest of the candidates though...some of these should be called a bit early if it's completely been run-away with.

 

[tigervixxxen]

100 votes?

Man, Bigras is stomping the rest of the candidates though...some of these should be called a bit early if it's completely been run-away with.

That's why I put this one up early because the other one had 100 votes and wasn't close. I know these polls won't get 100 for long but will also be much closer.

 

[AllAboutAvs]

Looking at the the names people want to add, it is cleared to me that we should have more than six names to choose from after this poll. Prospects are a lot closer to each others after Bigras and could go numerous ways.

 

[Nzap]

Bigras again clear choice.

Add Compher.

 

[landy92mack29]

Bigras

add Wood

 

[cgf]

hischon havent proven that he can play in NHL. he was given the chanse but didnt take it. you can say that 16 games is a small sample for pickard but he was our starter then and put upp great numbers.

You're kind of ignoring the whole point of people bringing up his sample size. Yes he looked great during that time, but that wasn't even close to enough time to prove he's an NHL starter. So him looking great during it is a lot better than if he had struggled, but it's not proof of anything yet.

 

[tigervixxxen]

With how many people pencil Hishon into the lineup next year, I'm actually a bit surprised nobody has suggested to add him yet.

 

[Tommy Shelby]

Easily Bigras.

Add Compher

 

[PAZ]

hischon havent proven that he can play in NHL. he was given the chanse but didnt take it. you can say that 16 games is a small sample for pickard but he was our starter then and put upp great numbers.

There's been plenty of goalies that get called up, have a great run, and then when they get thrown into a full seasons of work they show their flaws (Scrivens, Reimer, Enroth, Lindback, etc).

 

[CB Joe]

Bigras. Add Wood.

 

[bromando]

I'd say add Compher

 

[BK Avs]

Picks.

Add Hishon. Just cuz he's not as young and sexy as he once was, doesn't mean he's still not much closer to NHL ready than many of our other prospects.

 

[AvsFan2123]

Add wood

 

[member 116861]

Add Wood

 

[R S]

Bigras. Add Greer.

 

[Skip2myBordyloo]

Add Compher.