AuraSphere
Registered User
- Jun 27, 2012
- 4,234
- 2,325
Pouliot was an amazing player from what I saw in the memorial cup games, he will most def makes it over finn (my teams prospect) if not anyone else ;o
Pouliot was an amazing player from what I saw in the memorial cup games, he will most def makes it over finn (my teams prospect) if not anyone else ;o
To be fair, Ryan Murphy looked great in the OHL games, too.
Why were the 5 goals given up ? Bad D ? Goalie? Just a bad game overall ? The states almost final team was just too much for this group of players ?
Yup, TC management, always seems to pick flash, but you need the role players, we have plenty of offensively talented blue liners and forwards. Like I said best case scenario, we get some more physically intimidating kids out there and get those quick passes out of the zone, we don't need dmen trying to do it all themselves, we've seen enough of that in Murphy.
A Nurse-Ekblad pairing would be reminiscent of when we had the towers Aulie-Schenn help us to Gold.
As for Finn, yes I am a Leafs fan, but I'd give him a spot over Pouliot, he's better defensively and does play with a bit of an edge, all these kids can skate and put up points, why not take the ones who can defend aswell.
Pouliot's game is tailored for big ice... He is on another offensive and puck moving level than Finn. I really don't see how they don't take Pouliot considering Brent Sutter is the coach and Ryan Jankowski is based out of Calgary as well.
Anyone that gets a number of viewings of Pouliot can see the vision and instincts Pouliot brings - he simply has a different sense and feel for the game than most other d-men. He plays very relaxed and smooth, Murphy is more jumpy and operates in fits and starts, Pouliot has a very high panic threshold. I hated Ryan Murphy's from the first game I saw him, I have seen Pouliot play a ton and the comparisons are not apt at all.
I understand the basic premise of wanting well-rounded defensemen, but if there's one thing Pouliot isn't guilty of, it's trying to do it all himself. He's the best passing/playmaking defenseman available. He and Murphy are both offensive defensemen, but couldn't be more different in the way they produce offense.
I watched all 3 games so these are the players I would pick solely on that.
Domi- McDavid- Reinhart
Horvat- Monahan- Shinkaruk
Gaunce- Gauthier- Mantha
Rychel- Petan- Leipsic
Hudon
Matheson- Severson
Finn- Nurse
Koekkoek- Pouliot
Morrissey
Comrie
Fucale
Paterson
The defence and last few forwards were really hard to pick as a lot of guys did not impress me. Also a bunch of guys would have to play out of position. Again this is just the guys who I thought were the best in the three games.
I watched all 3 games so these are the players I would pick solely on that.
Domi- McDavid- Reinhart
Horvat- Monahan- Shinkaruk
Gaunce- Gauthier- Mantha
Rychel- Petan- Leipsic
Hudon
Matheson- Severson
Finn- Nurse
Koekkoek- Pouliot
Morrissey
Comrie
Fucale
Paterson
The defence and last few forwards were really hard to pick as a lot of guys did not impress me. Also a bunch of guys would have to play out of position. Again this is just the guys who I thought were the best in the three games.
Is Cody Ceci not available? He's 19 turning 20 on the 21st of December. When's the cut off?
PP lineups anyone? Just as a Canucks fan, I know Shinkaruk thrives playing the point with his wrister.
Domi-McDavid-Petan
Shinkaruk-______
Horvat-Monahan-Mantha
______-_______
Idk the defense very well yet, but those are 2 very different looks that may click.
not enough size on that first unit.PP lineups anyone? Just as a Canucks fan, I know Shinkaruk thrives playing the point with his wrister.
Domi-McDavid-Petan
Shinkaruk-______
Horvat-Monahan-Mantha
______-_______
Idk the defense very well yet, but those are 2 very different looks that may click.
Only thing about that first unit is you've got 3 playmakers up front. Total homer suggestion, but why not bump Mantha up and Petan down? If there's one place that Mantha can make an impact, it's on the PP along that right side.PP lineups anyone? Just as a Canucks fan, I know Shinkaruk thrives playing the point with his wrister.
Domi-McDavid-Petan
Shinkaruk-______
Horvat-Monahan-Mantha
______-_______
Idk the defense very well yet, but those are 2 very different looks that may click.
Pouliot was an amazing player from what I saw in the memorial cup games, he will most def makes it over finn (my teams prospect) if not anyone else ;o
I guess it depends. Poulliot did look good during the mem cup. Always so impressed with his offensive tools. Where he's really effective is something like zone entry/puck distribution on the power play, as he's an effortless skater/above avg puck distributor.
He is quite prone to turnovers/miscues though. CAN would likely offer him very sheltered minutes if he did make the team.
What do you guys think? I'm no expert so I may be underrating his defensive game. Also, does Canada ever take players on a WJC team and give them sheltered minutes?
Best case scenario for dmen IMO.
Rielly - Reinhart
Nurse - Ekblad
Finn - Dumba
Pouliot/Severson
Canada has lacked DFD for the past few years.
Not bad.
Last year I predicted a fourth place finish. I was right.
I'm back to predict that if we don't build around a BIG fast mobile defenders we will be doomed again.
Rielly if he is not with maple leafs will make it. Offensive
Reinhart 6'4" 207 can lay the body. Will make it. Defensive
That leaves 5 positions:
2 Ryan Pulock R/D 6’0.5” 211 10/06/94
3 Dillon Heatherington L/G 6’3” 196 Will make the team. Can skate and bang. Defensive
4 Matt Finn L/G 6’0” 207 will make it. Can skate and is tough. Defensive
5 Michael Matheson L/G 6’1.5” 178 02/27/94
6 Damon Severson R/D 6’2” 198 08/08/94
7 Josh Morrissey L/G 6’0” 184 03/28/95
15 Derrick Pouliot L/G 6’0” 192 will make it. Can skate and is offensive
24 Mathew Dumba R/D 6’0” 183 07/25/94
25 Darnell Nurse L/G 6’4” 189 02/04/95 will make the team on nastiness alone. Offensive
27 Slater Koekkoek L/G 6’2” 185 02/18/94
Aaron Ekblad 6'4" 215. Will make it due to his defensive attributes and size. Defensive
I pick defence who are tough can skate and can play defensively
Offensive d
Rielly
Nurse
Pouliot
Defensive d
Reinhart
Finn
Heatherington
Ekblad
I'm assuming we are taking only 7
Dumba will probably be on this team because of who his coach is. I'm just not sure who he will replace.
Sutter is not going with 1 right handed defensmen, the breakout will be abysmal.
I like the first one but the second one I would take Horvat off and put someone else. Hes not that great offensively compared to a lot of the guys on the team. I would put Shinkaruk in his place and use two dmen on both PPs
Hard to say... 16 goals in 21 playoff games last season. Seems like he may be a guy who should be on the power play in some sort of facet.