I didn't cite Markstrom's record just to show how bad Markstrom has been. There are plenty of other stats to prove that Markstrom has been...well, not good. The record is just proof of why it's so difficult to get excited about this franchise. Fans always end up being proven wrong and looking foolish. The fanbase has been excited about Markstrom for years and yet we're still terrible. Then again, that's probably not surprising since this franchise has been terrible with other, better goalies.
The record is not proof of anything. W-L is a team record. The truest indicator of a goalie's worth is SV%. W-L means nothing for goalies. Chris Osgood had some of the best W-L records for years. And BTW, Markstrom's stats aren't that much worse than Thomas' stats. Are you saying Thomas has been bad too? You can have a lot of fun with stats. I'm sorry, but Markstrom has not been terrible, as you make out. He can be better right now, but for a 23 year old he's playing OK, and the main thing is he's getting experience which is very important. I think a big part of why some Panthers fans are critical is because we have such a slim margin of error. We need our goalies to be mid-90's Hasek every game in order for us to have a chance to win. If Markstrom was in Pittsburgh, Boston, or L.A., he'd be getting a lot more complements right now. Yes, he's making some mistakes right now. A 23 year old goalie making some mistakes. Imagine that. It's going to happen. That doesn't make him a bust. That's just a joke to say that right now.
How long should we wait? Right now, it's no different than having Scott Clemmensen in net.
At least until he's 25? Do you think goalies should be fully developed at 21 or something? Most goalies don't come into their own until their mid-late 20's.
He's 23. He's 23. He's 23. He's 23. He's 23. He's 23. He's 23. He's 23. He's 23.
Roberto Luongo age 23.
194 GP
55 W -105 L (but Markstrom is playing behind a bad team!!!1!)
2.72 GAA
0.916 Sv%
16 SO
Not every goaltender is bad at age 23.
So because one goalie was a star at 23, every goalie has to be? Most goalies are not great at 23. Louie was a stud. Like Haj said, his performances in his last few seasons here were truly mind-boggling, I still don't know how he did it. He was the exception, not the rule.