I get that re: his eligibility last season, and it's too bad that he's either on the NHL club or has to go back to junior for this year, that's the downside of the NHL/CHL deal
No, no, no. This is what you're missing, any OHL player who played 20 AHL games last year is exempted from the CHL agreement. Byfield is allowed to play in the AHL this year. And despite being allowed to play in the AHL, he was going to be on the NHL roster.
But I wasn't under the impression he was a lock for the Kings team this season, at least not in the top 9. And if he's debuting on the 4th line, unless for a really shortened time period, that's not promising, least of all for his development.
He was, his play showed he deserved it and McClellan flat out said it. As for the role....we don't really know what our 2nd or 3rd line is, but the team wasn't going to let him languish on the 4th line all year. He averaged 15 minutes per game in his 6 game call up last year and looked every bit like he fit in.
As for the other forwards, I'm not suggesting any or all are or will be busts, but there's a reason Blake went out and got 3 forwards for his top 9 as this team clearly wants to take a leap forward and none of the youngsters is ready. My concern is that any hope that a few would significantly exceed expectations is in question. And to make the leap to playoff team they will need a few of them to do just that, esp. considering Kopitar and Doughty aren't going to be the stars forever.
If the best this group gets to (outside Byfield, and even he's not a sure thing) is a middle-6 forward or two or four, that won't get it done.
The reason has nothing to do with lack of confidence in the 20 year old prospects and everything to do with the lack of confidence in the 23-28 year old roster players. We have a "lost generation" of players due to trading so many high picks between 2011 - 2016 to try and win cups. The 28 year old Arvidsson and Danault signings are meant to bridge the gap between the 34 and 37 year old Kopitar and Brown and the 19-22 year old gluttony of prospects.
"My concern is that any hope that a few would significantly exceed expectations is in question" - there is no reason for that, the kids are playing outstanding right now, the eye test and their numbers reflect that. The team is simply trying to put the prospects in the best position to succeed while also getting results on the ice.