The rebuild talk is already started? Wow. And ya what many others have stated about what would you replace him with?
If anything I would've suggested that the Flyers take Fucale instead of Price. Price is in his prime right now and really there's nobody left to fill in for the Habs.
Fucale for probably Simmonds + C prospect? Laughton (although Philly loves him).
If Dubnyk isn't a good goalie - what's Price?I'm not seeing where we are getting a good goalie back.
If Dubnyk isn't a good goalie - what's Price?
and it wont happen
Philly wont be in the cards for Price
maybe TB ,Isles , Edmonton but not Philly
As a Flyers fan, I have to give a response to this post.No interest in Morin. Morin was one of Phillys first cuts at camp and has been below average since returning to the Q. Obviously Tinordi wasn't too hot in his first OHL season but Morin already has experience in the league and with the coach so there's no reason he shouldn't be doing well. I was going to cry if we drafted him at 25/would have been livid if we traded up at the draft. I was shocked(pleasantly surprised?) that someone took him just outside the top 10.
If Dubnyk isn't a good goalie - what's Price?
The best deal --->
To : Carey Price.
To : Jonathan Huberdeau or Aleksander Barkov + Erik Grudbranson + Jacob Markström.
But i really love Price and i would never trade him.
If anything I would've suggested that the Flyers take Fucale instead of Price. Price is in his prime right now and really there's nobody left to fill in for the Habs.
Fucale for probably Simmonds + C prospect? Laughton (although Philly loves him).
Yes, I said Dubnyk is better than Price. Fantastic job at reading what I wrote.Dubnyk is better than Price now?
Probably one of the more ignorant things I've read. Do you watch Dubnyk?You probably didnt watch Dubnyk much lol.. He is barely a NHL starter..
Price for Huberdeau would actually be worth considering. If you do this though, you are probably starting a rebuild because unless we luck out on a goalie this team would tank so fast. Our D already sucks and you take away a strong netminder I don't see us having any hope of making the playoffs.The best deal --->
To : Carey Price.
To : Jonathan Huberdeau or Aleksander Barkov + Erik Grudbranson + Jacob Markström.
But i really love Price and i would never trade him.
If I'm Edmonton I'd be worrying a lot more about defense than goaltending right now. There is no D there.Yes, I said Dubnyk is better than Price. Fantastic job at reading what I wrote.
I supposed the trade I proposed equals out because Gionta is clearly better than Eberle, right?
Probably one of the more ignorant things I've read. Do you watch Dubnyk?
I watch Edmonton a fair amount, especially last year because of Yakupov and Eberle.
Dubnyk, like Price, has trouble with the "softie per game." However, aside from that, he consistently puts up as good of numbers as Price on team whose #1 defenseman for years was Ryan Whitney (who was hurt 75% of the time, by the way).
Look, I'm critical of Price's technique/play on occasion, but this thread just... hurts my brain. There's no Halak beside him right now, and we've held onto him until he got to his prime, so how about we try to see some of his prime? We don't need to trade him at this point, he just has to play a teensy bit better.
Maybe, MAYbe, if another really good goalie was coming back, maybe one that only had 2 or 3 years left on their contract, maybe you start putting together something that makes more sense in the long term, but man... Price to Philadelphia? Already? Jesus no.
Sean is a legit big shutdown center already, screw plekanec and dd. You make that move and retool accordingly. Grab Fasth+ from Anaheim.
Morin is yoooouuuung and BIG. Let him develop some. Serious potential there.
yes lol goalie are overrated, the difference between price and budja is very small
Price's trade value is enormous, and based on his play the end of last season and the way he was fighting the puck in game one this year.... he ain't a sure bet. Be very, very difficult to actually trade him and there's no question we have no one who could be a #1 in his place. But it's more than a fair question. Price for Giroux is not a ridiculous trade, in and of itself. Price for Couturier and pieces.... no, couldn't do that.
Goaltending is the most important position in Hockey.
It's on par with Quarterback in the NFL.
Aaron Rodgers and Tom Brady are exceptional quarterbacks. Rodgers performs well without an OL.. Brady performs well without any weapons.. However, neither one of them can carry those teams all the way without support.
An exceptional goalie can get you far, win you games you should't win, but you can't win with just a goalie.
However, saying goaltending is overrated. No. You need an all-star team in front of a bad goalie to win it all. Even then, you're not guaranteed.. Niemi has shown after winning his cup that he's actually an above average goalie. Leighton sucked and that's why he let in the cup winning goal by Kane.
But him sucking never prevented them from getting there in the first place, makes perfect sense.
Goaltenders have marginal trade value for a reason.