Age 31, 1yr stats
Cain: 645pa, 115wrc+, 4.1fwar, 5.3bwar, 4.7awar650
Pagan: 305pa, 116wrc+, 1.4fwar, 0.8bwar, 2.3awar650
Byrd: 599pa, 103wrc+, 1.3fwar, 2.2bwar, 1.9awar650
3yr stats
Cain: 1683pa, 116wrc+, 13.1war, 15.4bwar, 5.5awar650
Pagan: 1496pa, 107wrc+, 6.9fwar, 6.0bwar, 2.8awar650
Byrd: 1515pa, 111wrc+, 6.8fwar, 8.9bwar, 3.4awar650
5yr stats
Cain: 2627pa, 108wrc+, 20.5fwar, 23.7bwar, 5.5awar650
Pagan: 2505pa, 110wrc+, 14.8fwar, 15.2bwar, 3.9awar650
Byrd: 2002pa, 104wrc+, 7.7fwar, 10.0bwar, 2.9awar650
Career
Cain: 3052pa, 107wrc+, 23.5fwar, 27.8bwar, 5.5awa650
Pagan: 2958pa, 106wrc+, 15.9fwar, 16.4bwar, 3.6awar650
Byrd: 2969pa, 98wrc+, 9.7fwar, 11.1bwar, 2.3awar650
Age 32-36
Cain: ?
Byrd: 2481pa, 108wrc+, 11.0fwar, 12.7bwar, 3.1awar650
Pagan: 1507pa, 96wrc+, 3.0fwar, 0.5bwar, 0.8awar650
Heck, even though they're not really good comparables, Byrd actually got better from ages 32-36, and would have been well worth this Cain contract.