The biggest reason to send Abby down is accountability. At the very least he should have his A taken away. He is playing some of the worst hockey in the league. Bottom 1% easy.
I understand a contract is a contract but the level of play he is bringing to the table needs some accountability and I don't think anyone outside of his circle of family and friends would object to him finishing his career in the AHL.
What I would say is this.
Who are our best PK forwards?
Here's where Abby ranked each year on GA/60, among DRW forwards with 100 minutes of PK time or more.
19-20 . 9.89 4th of 7. Ehn was the only one substantially better. Nobody was really much worse.
18-19 - 6.32. 2nd on the team behind DLR.
Over the previous 3 years - 5.55 - 2nd on the team behind Steve Ott (who had a very small sample size).
I don't see a ton of need to dump Abdelkader. If he returns to action and plays poorly again on the PK, then yeah. But if he resumes his role as a top PK guy, then send him out there on L4 and the PK.
We don't have anywhere else to spend the money. We don't have a lot of 4th line types dying for his spot.
Guys who he's competing with for jobs (Glendening/Helm) are nearing the end of their tenure here.
I don't see a screaming need to dump him at the moment.
And I am not a Justin Abdelkader fan by ANY stretch of the imagination.
The Abdelkader contract has already done its damage. The Abdelkader top 6 experiment has already done its damage.
This trojan virus as run its course.