BlueAndWhite
Registered User
God damn, that's twice I'm defending Leaf prospects in this thread alone.Beakermania said:And its not strange when you pick Coliacovo (shown little in any of his NHL games) over Komisarek (who looked real good in the playoffs).
We all have a bit of homerism in us, so don't be so critical when it u see it someone else.
P.S. i did go Steen over Loui
I'm just curious as to how 4 games is enough to determine whether Colaiacovo has shown little or lots ?
Did you watch the games ? Are you just going by the 2 points in 4 games? (I'm sincerely interested here, not trying to be sarcastic)
In my opinion, Colaiacovo looked very good in 2 of those games. And average in the other 2. However, 4 games playing limited minutes (around 13 minutes a game) is not enough to judge a young defenseman both in a positive and negative light.
By the same token - Komisarek played well in the playoffs (I wouldn't say "real good", though I did not watch all seven of his playoff games) but they were only seven games.
In his previous 67 NHL games, Komisarek hasn't shown me much and he's registered a mere 5 points (and yes I know point totals aren't everything).
I don't see what Komisarek has done so far (apart from his DECENT playoffs) to make you think that he is solidly ahead of Cola at this point ?
(and I guess this question goes out to anyone and everyone..because about 80% of the posters here, picked Komisarek)