Hahahaha, some crazy takes in here. We’re talking starting fresh no injury history. Karlsson’s injuries happened because of bad luck, not like Peter Forsberg who had chronic foot problems and was playing overly physically. Not only could Karlsson have been the hands down best Dman of a generation without that achilles injury (which he still probably was) but he could also have been a contender for the best player of a generation. This poll result just shows a massive lack of memory in here.