daver
Registered User
Hard to say right now. Basically we are talking about McDavid in 2021 and Crosby in 2011. Outside of the big 4 has anyone had a better start to their career (6 years) than McDavid other than perhaps Crosby? I'll say no even for Jagr from 1990-'96. Ray Bourque as well. Actually, come to think of it, did Gordie Howe have a better 6 year start to his career? Maybe not even. Granted, we all know how Howe's story ends and not even Gretzky was as consistently great for as many consecutive seasons, which is about 20. So my guess is McDavid doesn't have that sort of longevity, no one does, and even Howe in his 7th season did what McDavid did this year, if not better.
So this boils down to Crosby and McDavid. It all depends on what you figure was more valuable. Do the extra two Art Rosses make up for the Conn Smythe-like playoff runs Crosby had up until that point?
Up until Game 41 of this season, Crosby and McDavid were pretty much identical in offensive production through their first five and one half seasons. McDavid, has he has tended to do, went off at the end of this season as conditions for him to do so presented themselves.
Crosby adds a notably superior 2-way game, and a playoff resume that is perhaps unrivalled by any other player thru age 24 besides Wayne.