I really wish some of the Americans on ESPN FC would stop acting like this is the most talented group we've ever had or that we aren't in a down cycle. Herc is insufferable on this. We are weak all over the pitch compared to previous years except for maybe the spots where Pulisic will lineup in. I think sooner than later we'll be stronger at CB once the youngers guys finally get some time, but right now, that positions sucks too.
And even with as good as Pulisic is, since the team is weaker elsewhere, in certain games his effectiveness can be less than Donovan's or Dempsey's was.
I don't know that this group isn't better than some of the past sides that the US has put out. But what is true is that other nations that we probably could have steam rolled are much more competitive, and they're much better away from home. There was a good period of time in CONCACAF where other than going to just awful stadiums, the US could count on drubbing pretty much everyone other than Mexico at home. Then when Mexico ran into manager or player pool issues, even the US could beat them.
I'd make the argument, for what it's worth, Honduras, Costa Rica, Panama, and Mexico are all much better. When you compound that with the US going through a crappy overrated manager for a while, and many of their young players not getting experience or reaching their potential, we are where they are. I also think if you add in one more solid defender, and it's a bit of a different story, but I'm not sure that's possible.
However, there's an article in the ringer the other day promoting the u17 USA side, and what they recount is kinda true. The US has really failed to produce much in the last few cycles in the u17-u20 that's worth a ton. They've only gotten three or four players where they needed a lot more to overhaul the entire side. One of the things they don't account for is that with the explosion of the sport in the US to an extent with more and more opportunities for player development, as the young kids go overseas, it's a double edged sword. Sure, moving to Europe is fine and all, but if you're a 15 or 16 year old kid moving to Ajax or Dortmund or wherever, the chances of you getting playing time you need are not a sure thing. The step up is also massive.