I was watching the Canada-Russia Superseries last week and I noticed that the Q was once again losing to the Russians. In fairness, the Russians seem to have brought their "A" game this year, as they also beat the W twice and took Ontario to a shootout in one of the games.
I went and looked up the stats since the tournament's inception in 2003. The results for each league:
OHL: 16-0
WHL: 13-3
QMJHL: 9-7
Goals for and against:
OHL: 72-25
WHL: 73-33
QMJHL: 70-55
While the three leagues were pretty equal in terms of scoring, the Q lags way behind in terms of keeping the puck out of their own net. Which makes sense I guess, considering the lack of top-end talent the Q has produced on D and in goal over the last decade. The Canadian World Junior teams are a good resource too, as there usually only seems to be 3 or so QMJHL players on the roster each year.
I googled around a bit for more info, and found this link, which indicates that not only has the number of QMJHL players drafted stagnated since the 80's despite league expansion, but that less and less of the Q is actually made up of Quebec-born players every year.
In the last 5 drafts the OHL and WHL have produced nearly 40 first-rounders each, while the Q has produced just 10, with only 5 of them being from Quebec. The highest a QMJHL player has gone over that span is 7 (Voracek), and the highest a Quebec-born QMJHL player has gone is 11th (Bernier).
So what gives? the Q used to be goalie factory, but aside from Fleury and I guess Leclair really hasn't produced much of note in the 2000's. The trend of very few quality defensemen has continued from the 90's, and there really haven't been many (any?) superstar NHL forwards from the Q in the last decade (off the top of my head, Bergeron might be the best?). And highly-skilled finesse forwards used to be something you could always count on coming out of Quebec.
Any theories as to why the Q, and Quebec specifically, is lagging so far behind the other two Canadian junior leagues? Is it coaching? A decline in registered players? Internal league politics?
I went and looked up the stats since the tournament's inception in 2003. The results for each league:
OHL: 16-0
WHL: 13-3
QMJHL: 9-7
Goals for and against:
OHL: 72-25
WHL: 73-33
QMJHL: 70-55
While the three leagues were pretty equal in terms of scoring, the Q lags way behind in terms of keeping the puck out of their own net. Which makes sense I guess, considering the lack of top-end talent the Q has produced on D and in goal over the last decade. The Canadian World Junior teams are a good resource too, as there usually only seems to be 3 or so QMJHL players on the roster each year.
I googled around a bit for more info, and found this link, which indicates that not only has the number of QMJHL players drafted stagnated since the 80's despite league expansion, but that less and less of the Q is actually made up of Quebec-born players every year.
In the last 5 drafts the OHL and WHL have produced nearly 40 first-rounders each, while the Q has produced just 10, with only 5 of them being from Quebec. The highest a QMJHL player has gone over that span is 7 (Voracek), and the highest a Quebec-born QMJHL player has gone is 11th (Bernier).
So what gives? the Q used to be goalie factory, but aside from Fleury and I guess Leclair really hasn't produced much of note in the 2000's. The trend of very few quality defensemen has continued from the 90's, and there really haven't been many (any?) superstar NHL forwards from the Q in the last decade (off the top of my head, Bergeron might be the best?). And highly-skilled finesse forwards used to be something you could always count on coming out of Quebec.
Any theories as to why the Q, and Quebec specifically, is lagging so far behind the other two Canadian junior leagues? Is it coaching? A decline in registered players? Internal league politics?
Last edited: