seventieslord
Student Of The Game
Roy is definitely getting a call.
King and Ververgaert came very close to making the cut.
Suter has been good, but he's not there yet.
Frolov has simply been too inconsistent. At 28, he's about to play his way out of the NHL for good. After I've unveiled my 12 offensive LWs we can talk about whether he is more deserving than them.
Lessard? Yes he was a 2nd team all-star, but that was all because of his league-leading win total. He was 10th in sv% twice, and that was it. Career sv% was .875, below the league average during his career. And boy, was it awfully short. A record of 92-97? Hec Fowler and Hal Winkler both have records similar to that, except they played when the seasons were 24-30 games long.
Bergevin was a career #5-7 defenseman. We shouldn't be picking guys just for lasting a long time.
King and Ververgaert came very close to making the cut.
Suter has been good, but he's not there yet.
Frolov has simply been too inconsistent. At 28, he's about to play his way out of the NHL for good. After I've unveiled my 12 offensive LWs we can talk about whether he is more deserving than them.
Lessard? Yes he was a 2nd team all-star, but that was all because of his league-leading win total. He was 10th in sv% twice, and that was it. Career sv% was .875, below the league average during his career. And boy, was it awfully short. A record of 92-97? Hec Fowler and Hal Winkler both have records similar to that, except they played when the seasons were 24-30 games long.
Bergevin was a career #5-7 defenseman. We shouldn't be picking guys just for lasting a long time.
Last edited: