Brian39
Registered User
- Apr 24, 2014
- 7,140
- 13,100
Teams wont pay more then rental price. Given who Tavares is, that's a 1st+a good prospect. No ones gutting their pool for a guy thats going to walk. Now if there are multiple teams he's willing to sign with....well then things will get ugly
We're going to have to agree to disagree that rental Tavares is worth just slightly more than rental Shatty or rental Hanzal. I realize that Sanford is worth less than the 'good prospect' you intend and the same can be said about the 2nd rounder and conditional 3rd the Wild included for Hanzal.
However, the difference between those add ons and the prospect you are talking about is not the difference between Shatty/Hanzal and Tavares.
If Tavares is traded as a rental, he will probably be the best and most sought after rental ever. Ray Bourque, Ron Francis, and Gretzky to the Blues are up there too, but Gretzky was 35 and Bourque was almost 40. Regardless of whether he is the best rental or just up there, this would be a way better player than the average top 6 guy who is available at the deadline. Hossa to the Pens is probably the closest comparable in the cap era and he garnered a 1st, A Esposito (20th overall a year earlier), and 2 legitimate roster players with some upside in Colby Armstrong and Erik Christensen (the Thrashers also traded Dupuis to the Pens, so probably cancel out Christensen to a degree since Christensen's production was just a bit better than Dupuis' at the time).
As great as Hossa was, I think most people would agree that a 27 year old Tavares should have more value than a 29 year old Hossa.
A 1st and a team's best or 2nd best prospect will likely be the base of the trade, but you're also going to have to throw in a piece or two that can contribute to the Isles in some way immediately. Maybe that's a 3rd line forward and your 4th or 5th best D man. Maybe it's a couple depth forwards. Maybe it's 1 roster player and a B level prospect who is a bit older. But it will be more than just a 1st and a good prospect.