Slafkovsky vs Marner for a playoff run

[Despote]

Which player would you rather add on your team for a playoff run right now?

Click to read more...

 

[David Suzuki]

I've never seen Slafkovsky crying in the penalty box I'll tell you that much

 

[LeafsNation149]

lock it up

 

[Jetcetera]

Marner disappears every playoff so picked slav

 

[Leafidelity]

Hfboards is not a serious site

 

[Junohockeyfan]

Slaf because he blows Knies out of the water!

 

[GOilers88]

Until Slaf plays some playoff games I don't know how you couldn't pick Marner. He's the better player right now, regardless of his past playoff performances.

Though I do think Slaf continues to become a monster as he grows. Really like the player. But these are some seriously loaded poll options, especially since we don't even know what Slaf's prime will look like.

 

[BraveCanadian]

If Slaf becomes half as good as Marner is he’d be doing alright.. ridiculous poll

 

[34]

lol is this a serious poll.

Trying to compare a bust 19 goal scorer to Marner. Come on.

 

[LEAFANFORLIFE23]

39% of people took the guy who Isn't going to be in the playoffs.

and you wonder why HF boards is seen as anti Leaf.

39% of voters are not serious people

 

[Kiorei]

Marner until I see what Slaf can do in the playoffs. He's going to be such a stud though.

 

[RedWingzz]

gotta love Montreal fans on HF lol

Slaf has a decent season, and all of a sudden he's Pavel Bure

 

[Atomos2]

What a joke. Get in the playoffs first then talk about playoffs. This is Stutzle - Matthews all over again.

 

[DudeWhereIsMakar]

I think Slavkovsky will be that wing who will carry their team rather than it being a centreman.

 

[Fledgemyhedge]

lol is this a serious poll.

Trying to compare a bust 19 goal scorer to Marner. Come on.

Interesting when you look up how many goals marner scored his d+ 2 season..

 

[Kudo Shinichi]

39% of people took the guy who Isn't going to be in the playoffs.

and you wonder why HF boards is seen as anti Leaf.

39% of voters are not serious people

What a joke. Get in the playoffs first then talk about playoffs. This is Stutzle - Matthews all over again.

Why does a player need to have played in the playoffs to be taken over Marner? Marner has already shown many times that he's not good in the playoffs. It won't difficult for a player to perform better than Marner in the playoffs.

Bedard and B. Tkachuk have never played in the nhl playoffs. Would anyone really take Marner over either of them for a playoff run?

 

[LPHabsFan]

Mitch Marner has put up 663 points in 572 games over the course of his career. Slaf is 20, still developing, and development is never linear.

I would love for Slaf to be able to put up even 3/4 of Marners point production.

Stop with this stupidity.

 

[All Mod Cons]

Oh my actual f***

 

[bobholly39]

Option 3

Possibly option 2, but we'll see

 

[Xirik]

what it comes down to me for is which has the better chance.

Does Marner further adapts to playoff hockey like he has the past two playoffs or is Slafkovsky as a playoff rookie going going to do what not blast past the playoff hump that many young players experience when they get a taste of the playoffs.

Right now the easy bet is Marner.

I do think prime Slafkovsky will be better then prime Marner though.

 

[LEAFANFORLIFE23]

Why does a player need to have played in the playoffs to be taken over Marner? Marner has already shown many times that he's not good in the playoffs. It won't difficult for a player to perform better than Marner in the playoffs.

Bedard and B. Tkachuk have never played in the nhl playoffs. Would anyone really take Marner over either of them for a playoff run?

It's extremely difficult for a player to perform better than Marner in the playoffs when they don't get there, impossible in fact.

 

[DueDiligence]

I've never seen Slafkovsky crying in the penalty box I'll tell you that much

I've seen Slaf laughing when the Habs are losing many times

 

[The90]

Interesting when you look up how many goals marner scored his d+ 2 season..

How come you never talked about points?

 

[Atomos2]

Why does a player need to have played in the playoffs to be taken over Marner? Marner has already shown many times that he's not good in the playoffs. It won't difficult for a player to perform better than Marner in the playoffs.

Bedard and B. Tkachuk have never played in the nhl playoffs. Would anyone really take Marner over either of them for a playoff run?

Last year in the playoffs Marner had 14 pts in 11 games

Year before that 8 pts in 7 games.

I don’t even know why I’m bringing this up. I’m comparing these stats literally to nothing. Because that’s what Slaf is in the playoffs. Literally nothing.

Make the playoffs twice then argue when Slaf goes ppg+ in two playoff appearances.

 

[The Gr8 Dane]

Close it up , I'll vote slaf tho in honor of the thread