Proposal: RNH + EDM 2018 1st(+?) for Dumba and Zucker

[Filthy Dangles]

If Wild decide to rebuild, they get a center whose still youngish, a decade younger than current 1C Koivu and a really high pick.

Edmonton get the RHD they need and someone to play with McDavid. Zucker whose an RFA,could probably pot 40 with McD.

Thoughts? Is the value off? What would Edmonton have to add?

Click to read more...

 

[FrodoBeggins]

I want to clarify. RNH = Zuker, and the Dumba = 9 OA?

 

[Vancouver Canucks]

I want to clarify. RNH = Zuker, and the Dumba = 9 OA?

Well, the thing is the picks haven't been too kind towards the Oilers.

 

[DRW204]

Dumba probably worth more than the 9th OA

 

[Vancouver Canucks]

Dumba probably worth more than the 9th OA

Ehhhh....

 

[LTIR]

I want to clarify. RNH = Zuker, and the Dumba = 9 OA?

If RNH = Zuker then Edm shouldn't trade him..
Dumba is easily worth more than the 9OA IMO..

 

[DRW204]

Ehhhh....

Offensive Dman who has been steadily improving his point production each year and just hit 50 pts. 23 years old and looked good in the playoffs despite being quite overplayed. IDK i think he's worth more. OPs thread is based on the Wild rebuilding, why are they trading Dumba?

 

[Vancouver Canucks]

Offensive Dman who has been steadily improving his point production each year and just hit 50 pts. 23 years old and looked good in the playoffs despite being quite overplayed. IDK i think he's worth more. OPs thread is based on the Wild rebuilding, why are they trading Dumba?

He just wants to stir up the whole roster.

 

[ConnorMcMullet]

If Wild decide to rebuild, they get a center whose still youngish, a decade younger than current 1C Koivu and a really high pick.

Edmonton get the RHD they need and someone to play with McDavid. Zucker whose an RFA,could probably pot 40 with McD.

Thoughts? Is the value off? What would Edmonton have to add?

Interesting deal that I would probably consider. Dumba would be a great fit on the Oilers, but trading RNH hurts, since he's shown some great chemistry with McDavid recently. Would Puljujarvi work instead? Or Strome + Bear + 2nd?

Solid Offer.

 

[Goose312]

Dumba probably worth more than the 9th OA

Drafted 7th overall and just finished 19th in defender scoring at 23 while also play very good defense this season. Yep, not trading him for 9th OA.

 

[Goose312]

For the actual offer, it's not completely awful but it's also a no from the Wild. If they do rebuild I'm not sure why they trade their 23 year old stud defenseman who finally became the player the fans have been aching to get for an older center with 3 seasons left on his UFA expiring deal?

If the Wild do decide to retool or rebuild Dumba is probably the last guy to go and it would be for a solid long term core piece, which RNH + 9th OA isn't.

 

[JPeeper]

Ehhhh....

Dumba went 7th and is actually a good defender already in the NHL. He's worth more than a lottery ticket.

 

[Vancouver Canucks]

Dumba went 7th and is actually a good defender already in the NHL. He's worth more than a lottery ticket.

However, why is Minnesota trading Dumba?

 

[Goose312]

However, why is Minnesota trading Dumba?

OP isn't a Wild fan. As I said, Dumba would be the last guy to go in any potential rebuild or retool.

 

[TaLoN]

sorry, no, please end thread, Dumba is a non - starter. He's not being moved.

Granlund and Dumba are the two truly untouchable players.

 

[Vancouver Canucks]

OP isn't a Wild fan. As I said, Dumba would be the last guy to go in any potential rebuild or retool.

Ah, okay.

 

[TaLoN]

If Wild decide to rebuild, they get a center whose still youngish, a decade younger than current 1C Koivu and a really high pick.

Edmonton get the RHD they need and someone to play with McDavid. Zucker whose an RFA,could probably pot 40 with McD.

Thoughts? Is the value off? What would Edmonton have to add?

Ok, you want Dumba, put McDavid on the table and we'll talk, otherwise, no conversation to be had.

 

[Goose312]

Ok, you want Dumba, put McDavid on the table and we'll talk, otherwise, no conversation to be had.

If Drai's involved there's a deal that could be reached which I'm sure is also a total "no" from EDM fans, but to your point those are the only 2 players that move the needle enough for Dumba to even be considered.

 

[Filthy Dangles]

Ok, you want Dumba, put McDavid on the table and we'll talk, otherwise, no conversation to be had.

lol come on....

 

[ThePhoenixx]

Ok, you want Dumba, put McDavid on the table and we'll talk, otherwise, no conversation to be had.

He's not a wild fan or an Oiler fan.

 

[Bazeek]

Doesn't tempt me to move Dumba.

 

[GirardSpinorama]

Take out Zucker and add something less significant for the Wild (maybe Coyle?).

Dumba + Coyle for RNH + 9th overall.

 

[2Pair]

Take out Zucker and add something less significant for the Wild (maybe Coyle?).

Dumba + Coyle for RNH + 9th overall.

It would have to be Dumba for RNH and the pick, nothing added from Minnesota. Even then, I think the Wild decline.

 

[Digitalbooya]

Ok, you want Dumba, put McDavid on the table and we'll talk, otherwise, no conversation to be had.

f*** dude, you went there...

 

[GirardSpinorama]

It would have to be Dumba for RNH and the pick, nothing added from Minnesota. Even then, I think the Wild decline.

Ya I would think any team trading for a young player breaking out will have to overpay.