Music: Rank your favorite band/artist discography

[BonMorrison]

Coheed and Cambria

1a. No World for Tomorrow - 5/5
1b. Good Apollo I'm Burning Star IV vol I - 5/5

2. In Keeping Secrets of Silent Earth: 3 - 4.5/5

3. Year of the Black Rainbow - 4/5

4. Second Stage Turbine Blade - 4/5

5. The Afterman: Descension - 4/5

6. The Afterman: Ascension - 3.5/5

I'm going to be murdered for putting Year of the Black Rainbow so high but I really enjoyed that album. I know a lot of fellow Coheed fans saw it as a weak album but I thought it was great.

I also rank YotBR highly . That said, I don't rank Good Apollo Vol. 1 as high. I'd probably go:

In Keeping Secrets 3 - 10/10
Afterman: Ascension - 9/10
No World For Tomorrow - 9/10
Year of the Black Rainbow - 8.5/10
Afterman: Descension - 8.5/10
Second Stage Turbine - 8/10
Good Apollo Vol. 1 - 7.5/10

 

[brendan]

My Bloody Valentine just for kicks

1. Loveless - 112423423411000/100
2. m b v - 95/100
3. Isn't Anything - 93/100

 

[davemess]

someone do zeppelin

1) 4
2) 2
3) 1
4) 3

 

[davemess]

Seriously this time

1) Led Zeppelin IV
2) Houses of the Holy
3) Physical Graffiti
4) Led Zeppelin II
5) Led Zeppelin III
6) Led Zeppelin
7) Presence
8) In Through the Out Door
9) Coda

 

[plank]

RICHMOND FONTAINE


Thirteen Cities 10/10
Winnemucca 10/10
We Used to Think the Freeway Sounded Like A River 9.5/10
Obliteration by Time 9.5/10
The Fitzgerald 9.5/10
Live at the Doug Fir 9/10
Lost Son 8.5/10
Post to Wire 8.5/10
You Can't Go Back if There's Nothing to Go Back to 8/10
$87 and a Guilty Conscience 8/10
Miles From 8/10
The High Country 7.5/10
Safety 7.5/10
Postcard from Portland: Live at Dante's 7/10
Whiskey, Painkillers and Speed 7/10
Live at Satyricon 6/10

 

[Captain Bowie]

Matthew Good (Band or no Band):

1. Hospital Music
2. Avalanche
3. Beautiful Midnight
4. Vancouver
5. Underdogs
6. Last of the Ghetto Astronauts
7. Lights of Endangered Species
8. White Light Rock & Roll Review
9. Audio of Being
10. Arrows of Desire (to be fair haven't listened to it much).

 

[zombie kopitar]

Beatles Albums
Revolver
Abbey Road
Magical Mystery Tour
Rubber Soul
White Album
Sgt Peppers
Beatles for Sale
Hard Days Night
the rest

Arcade Fire
Funeral
Neon Bible
The Suburbs
Reflektor

Red Hot Chili Peppers
Californication
By The Way
Stadium Arcadium
Blood Sugar
the non Frusciante stuff

Jimi Hendrix
Electric Ladyland
Axis Bold as Love
Are You Experienced

Nirvana
MTV Unplugged
Nevermind
In Utero
Bleach

 

[stan the caddy]

I also rank YotBR highly . That said, I don't rank Good Apollo Vol. 1 as high. I'd probably go:

In Keeping Secrets 3 - 10/10
Afterman: Ascension - 9/10
No World For Tomorrow - 9/10
Year of the Black Rainbow - 8.5/10
Afterman: Descension - 8.5/10
Second Stage Turbine - 8/10
Good Apollo Vol. 1 - 7.5/10

Second Stage is as good as anything they put out, imo. That album kicks ****ing ass right from the start and doesn't stop. Every single song is great. God Send Conspirator is really underrated.

1A. Second Stage Turbine Blade
1B. In Keeping Secrets
2. Good Apollo 1
3. Good Apollo 2
4. Afterman
5. Year of the Black Rainbow

 

[Roboturner913]

Seriously this time

1) Led Zeppelin IV
2) Houses of the Holy
3) Physical Graffiti
4) Led Zeppelin II
5) Led Zeppelin III
6) Led Zeppelin
7) Presence
8) In Through the Out Door
9) Coda

STRONG DISAGREEMENT WILL ROBINSON

1. Physical Graffiti
2. IV
3. I
4. III
5. Houses of the Holy
6. II
7. Presence
8. In Through the Out Door

Coda is leftovers, does not count

 

[HarryLime]

Beatles Albums
Revolver
Abbey Road
Magical Mystery Tour
Rubber Soul
White Album
Sgt Peppers
Beatles for Sale
Hard Days Night
the rest

Arcade Fire
Funeral
Neon Bible
The Suburbs
Reflektor

Red Hot Chili Peppers
Californication
By The Way
Stadium Arcadium
Blood Sugar
the non Frusciante stuff

Jimi Hendrix
Electric Ladyland
Axis Bold as Love
Are You Experienced

Nirvana
MTV Unplugged
Nevermind
In Utero
Bleach

MMT too high for me, but solid list.

 

[HarryLime]

Seriously this time

1) Led Zeppelin IV
2) Houses of the Holy
3) Physical Graffiti
4) Led Zeppelin II
5) Led Zeppelin III
6) Led Zeppelin
7) Presence
8) In Through the Out Door
9) Coda

LZ is the toughest to rank for me

 

[Porn*]

Incubus:

SCIENCE
Make Yourself
Fungusamongus
Morning View
If not now, when?
A Crow left of the Murder
Light Grenades

Left out EPs, Live albums and compilations.

 

[Mach85]

The Gaslight Anthem:

The '59 Sound
Handwritten
Sink or Swim
American Slang

Silversun Pickups:

Carnavas
Swoon
Pikul EP
Neck of the Woods

Eminem:

The Eminem Show
MMLP
SSLP
MMLP2
Relapse
Recovery
Encore

Haven't listened to all of Infinite

 

[plank]

WILCO

Summerteeth 9.5/10
Sky Blue Sky 9.5/10
Being There 9/10
Mermaid Avenue Vol. ll 9/10
A.M. 8.5/10
Wilco 8.5/10
Yankee Hotel Foxtrot 8/10
The Whole Love 8/10
Kicking Television: Live in Chicago 8/10
Mermaid Avenue 7.5/10
Star Wars 7/10
A Ghost is Born 5/10
Schmilco 4/10


STEVE EARLE


Transcendental Blues 10/10
El Corazon 9/10
Train a Comin' 9/10
Guitar Town 9/10
I Feel Alright 9/10
So You Wannabe an Outlaw 8.5/10
Copperhead Road 8/10
Exit O 7/10
Townes 7/10
The Mountain 6/10
The Hard Way 5/10

 

[Nemesis Prime]

Chevelle:

1) Sci-Fi Crimes
2) Vena Sera
3) Wonder What's Next
4) Hats Off to the Bull
5) La Gárgola
6) This Type of Thinking
7) Point #1

I'd bump This Type of Thinking to 3 and every thing just moves down after that. That's just my opinion. Pretty good rankings, though.

Metallica:

...And Justice for All
Ride the Lightning
Death Magnetic
Load

Kill 'em All
Master of Puppets
Black Album
St. Anger
Reload

After Load, they're pretty much interchangeable for me.

 

[Mach85]

I'd bump This Type of Thinking to 3 and every thing just moves down after that. That's just my opinion. Pretty good rankings, though.

For me, it's:

1) Sci-Fi Crimes
2) Wonder What's Next
3) Vena Sera
4) Hats Off to the Bull
5) This Type of Thinking
6) La Gárgola
7) Point #1

 

[qc]

Talking Heads (studio albums.. Stop Making Sense is in my top 3 of all time favorite live albums/concert films)

Speaking In Tongues
More Songs About Buildings & Food
'77
Remain in Light
Little Creatures
Naked
True Stories

 

[Shareefruck]

Talking Heads (studio albums.. Stop Making Sense is in my top 3 of all time favorite live albums/concert films)

Speaking In Tongues
More Songs About Buildings & Food
'77
Remain in Light
Little Creatures
Naked
True Stories

No Fear of Music? That's my favorite one.

 

[qc]

No Fear of Music? That's my favorite one.

Complete forgot about it, good catch.

FWIW I put it slightly below '77 on my list, but the gap in quality between my top 6 choices is small. Don't get me wrong - I enjoy Little Creatures ,Naked, & True Stories- but I'd put them tier 1b.

 

[McPuritania]

Faith No More

Not going to include live albums and compilations.

1. Angel Dust
2. King for a Day...Fool for a Lifetime
3. The Real Thing
4. Album of the Year
5. Introduce Yourself

Metallica
1. Master of Puppets
2. ...And Justice for All
3. Ride the Lightning
4. Kill 'Em All
5. Metallica
6. Death Magnetic
7. Reload
8. Load
9. St. Anger

I'd bump This Type of Thinking to 3 and every thing just moves down after that. That's just my opinion. Pretty good rankings, though.

Metallica:

...And Justice for All
Ride the Lightning
Death Magnetic
Load

Kill 'em All
Master of Puppets
Black Album
St. Anger
Reload

After Load, they're pretty much interchangeable for me.

Metallica

1. ...And Justice for All
2. Kill 'Em All
3. Master of Puppets
4. Ride the Lightning
5. Death Magnetic
6. The Black Album (Self titled)
7. Reload
8. Load
9. St. Anger

Rammstein

1. Reise, Reise
2. Rosenrot
3. Mutter
4. Herzeleid
5. Liebe ist für alle da
6. Sehnsucht

This was fun, I'm gonna have to come back and do the rest of my favourite bands.

 

[Yung Rotini]

Eminem:
MMLP (9.5/10)
The Eminem Show (9/10)
Slim Shady LP (8.5/10)
MMLP 2 (8.5/10)
Relapse (7/10)
Recovery (5.5/10)
Encore (3/10)

Kendrick Lamar:
GKMC (9/10)
Section.80 (8/10)

 

[EdmontonFanatic]

Arctic Monkeys

1. Favorite Worst Nightmare

2. Whatever People Say I Am, That's What I'm Not

3. Suck It and See

4. Humbug

5. AM

 

[Mach85]

Arctic Monkeys

1. Favorite Worst Nightmare

2. Whatever People Say I Am, That's What I'm Not

3. Suck It and See

4. Humbug

5. AM

To each their own, but I thought AM was some of their best work. Different sound than they started out with though.

 

[EdmontonFanatic]

To each their own, but I thought AM was some of their best work. Different sound than they started out with though.

AM was decent, but I liked their earlier work better.

 

[plank]

JASON MOLINA (Songs: Ohia , Magnolia Electric Co., solo, etc.)


The Magnolia Electric Company - S:O 10/10
Nashville Moon(sojourner) - MEC 10/10
Didn't it Rain S:O 10/10
What Comes After the Blues - MEC 9.5/10
Trials & Errors - MEC 9.5/10
Ghost Tropic - S:O 9/10
Josephine - MEC 9/10
Fading Trails - MEC 9/10
Axxess & Ace -S:0 9/10
Black Ram(sojourner) - MEC 9/10
Lioness - S:O 8.5/10
Hard to Love a Man - MEC 8.5/10
Amalgamated Sons of Rest - ASOR 8/10
Let Me Go, Let Me Go, Let Me Go - JM 8/10
Pyramid Electric Co. - JM 8/10
Sun Session(sojourner) - MEC 8/10
Shohola(sojourner) - MEC 7.5/10
Mi Sei Apparso Come un Fantasma - S:O 7.5/10
Protection Spells - S:O 7.5/10
Songs:Ohia - S:O 7.5/10
Hecla & Griper - S:O 7/10
It's Made Me Cry - MEC 7/10
Impala - S:O 6.5/10
Autumn Bird Songs - JM 5.5/10
Molina & Johnson - M/J 5/10
The Ghost - S:O 4/10