it might been seen as sacrilege but why try Holl on the PP, he seems to want to be more offensive and has a decent shot; unfortunately a move like that would probably seen as an indictment on Reilly and a trade must be imminent :|
He has decent speed and is listed at 6'4" so his reach should help I'd give him a shot at least on the second PP, until a guy like Sandin gets a shot
I've been thinking about this as well, and if Matthews is going to play on the right wall for a 1 timer, a right shot is needed at the top. Allowing Matthews to touch the puck back up top for another 1 timer would help the powerplay a lot. Having Rielly at the top hurts in this aspect. For this reason, it make Rielly better suited for the 2nd unit as well seeing as the shooters are both right handed on the second unit (Nylander & Spezza).
But even still the Powerplay units need to be revamped. If Matthews injury is still affecting his shot that it makes him less effective taking shots, then he should be moved to the bumper position or even net front for tips. Probably net front as more shots would come from the half walls as opposed to the point. Put Hyman as the bumper, with Nylander on the left wall for 1 timers, Marner on the right, and you could still have Rielly at the point.
Second unit should be Simmonds net front, Tavares bumper, Spezza & Galchenyuk half walls with Brodie or whoever at the point. This depends on if Spezza would play the left wall over the right. If he feels he is better on the right wall, then you could swap Spezza to the first unit with either Nylander or Marner.