With Edler injured they really need Hamhuis. Their defense is struggling now without him they may as well blow it up. If they trade him they have given up, so I don't see them doing that. If Edler were healthy then maybe they could move him.
I am against getting late first round draft picks for players they can use, or just accumulating a bunch of picks. To me the draft is weak. McSaviour was sooo last year. I would much prefer the vets we trade return defensive prospects who play the right side. Now that Buff is off the table, there is no one on defense that I am excited about who are UFAs. Trading for a prospect is our best hope to fill a vital need. Looking at next year we could have a competitive D if we resign Hammer and get one good right side D:
Tanev Edler
NEED Hamhuis
Sbisa Hutton
Biega Pedan
My hope is their biggest NEED is filled at the trade deadline.
Unlike the tank crowd, I don't want to see 'selling' of any kind between now and deadline day. Management needs to give players the vote of confidence that if the team is fighting hard enough and is within playoff contention, then management will absolutely support them. It sends a TERRIBLE message to players if your management 'pulls the rug' underneath you 2-3 weeks before deadline day.
Sell sell sell
"If you and Jim conclude in the next couple of weeks that the best course of action is to trade some of the veterans - in other words, become sellers - is there a chance that ownership is gonna step in the way and say, 'No, you can't do that?'"
"No, absolutely not, Jason. That does not concern me at all. If that's the path we go down, we have the ability to do that. Ownership has been supportive [of] the moves we've made this year, and obviously...[there's been] some hard decisions on some veteran players - and expensive decisions - but there's been complete support there and I would expect that to continue."
Again, it all depends on where we are as a team come trade deadline day. If we're within 2-3 points of a playoff spot, we'll be buyers. However - if we're anywhere between 4+ points out with other teams having games in hand, then we'll be sellers. Period.
Unlike the tank crowd, I don't want to see 'selling' of any kind between now and deadline day. Management needs to give players the vote of confidence that if the team is fighting hard enough and is within playoff contention, then management will absolutely support them. It sends a TERRIBLE message to players if your management 'pulls the rug' underneath you 2-3 weeks before deadline day.
Now obviously - if we aren't where we need to be as a team come deadline day, then by all means, sell. However - do not sell every Tom, Dick, and Harry over the age of 27.
-Move Vrbata for a 2nd (I'd say 1st but I can't see it happening). I would actually consider moving Vrbata regardless of whether we're in playoff contention or not (if we're in contention, then only move Vrbata for a 1st otherwise keep him).
-Move Hamhuis for a 1st (a.k.a. The "Vermette" deal where we re-sign him in the off-season).
-Do whatever you can to move Prust or Higgins (although it's likely a no-go at this point).
-If a team is absurd enough to take on Burrows' contract (a la Bieksa/Anaheim), move Burrows and run.
-If someone gives us an unbelievable offer for Hansen or Miller (i.e. 1st rounder), take it and run (I can't see it happening though).
However - IF we are buyers.
-Consider trading 2nd's for highly talented 20-23 year olds that for whatever reason, haven't panned out on their original teams. For example - what Benning did with Baertschi and Vey. Only thing I'd do differently here is focusing on defensemen.
-If you're going to make a true 'hockey' deal, get some young guy aged 22-26 that can help us win now and in the future.
-If you're going to bring in a Brandon Prust type guy again, offer a 4th or 5th at most that will be a UFA at season's end.
On these terms, you can buy. I think what scares most Canuck fans are moves like a 2nd round pick for old vets like Derek Roy. I don't see Benning doing anything like this. Certain posters also have this notion in their heads that Benning will try and trade for a guy like Ladd, but this won't happen (unless I myself have misunderstood Benning and his intentions).
p.s._______________As for my vote, I'll have to vote 'neither' right now because I won't have my mind made up until the actual deadline day or the day before. Come to think of it, if it was up to me, I'd consider doing BOTH if I was Benning (with whom I'd target listed above).
Sell! All merchandise must be liquidated! No reasonable offer refused.
I'm expecting a Zombo trade deadline GDT at this rate
Player Team Pos Age Status Salary
[LIST=1]
[*]Steven Stamkos TBL C 25 UFA 2016 $7,500,000
[*]Eric Staal CAR C 31 UFA 2016 $8,250,000
[*]Jonathan Drouin TBL LW 20 RFA 2017 $894,000
[*]Tyler Ennis BUF C/RW 26 UFA 2019 $4,600,000
[*]Kevin Shattenkirk STL D 27 UFA 2017 $4,250,000
[*]Ryan Nugent-Hopkn EDM C 22 RFA 2020 $6,000,000
[*]Andrew Ladd WPG LW 30 UFA 2016 $4,400,000
[*]Mikkel Boedker ARZ RW 26 UFA 2016 $3,750,000
[*]Jordan Eberle EDM RW 25 RFA 2019 $6,000,000
[*]Travis Hamonic NYI D 25 UFA 2020 $3,857,000
[*]Kyle Okposo NYI RW 27 UFA 2016 $2,800,000
[*]Cam Atkinson CBJ RW 26 UFA 2018 $3,500,000
[*]Sami Vatanen ANA D 24 RFA 2016 $1,250,000
[*]Keith Yandle NYR D 29 UFA 2016 $2,625,000
[*]Cam Fowler ANA D 24 RFA 2018 $4,000,000
[*]Jiri Hudler CGY C/LW 33 UFA 2016 $4,000,000
[*]Loui Eriksson BOS RW 30 UFA 2016 $4,250,000
[*]Milan Lucic LAK LW 27 UFA 2016 $3,250,000
[*]Tyler Bozak TOR C 29 UFA 2019 $4,200,000
[*]Kris Russell CGY D 28 UFA 2016 $2,600,000
[/LIST]
Here are the players I think may be in play at the TDL.
Code:Player Team Pos Age Status Salary [LIST=1] [*]Steven Stamkos TBL C 25 UFA 2016 $7,500,000 [*]Eric Staal CAR C 31 UFA 2016 $8,250,000 [*]Jonathan Drouin TBL LW 20 RFA 2017 $894,000 [*]Tyler Ennis BUF C/RW 26 UFA 2019 $4,600,000 [*]Kevin Shattenkirk STL D 27 UFA 2017 $4,250,000 [*]Ryan Nugent-Hopkn EDM C 22 RFA 2020 $6,000,000 [*]Andrew Ladd WPG LW 30 UFA 2016 $4,400,000 [*]Mikkel Boedker ARZ RW 26 UFA 2016 $3,750,000 [*]Jordan Eberle EDM RW 25 RFA 2019 $6,000,000 [*]Travis Hamonic NYI D 25 UFA 2020 $3,857,000 [*]Kyle Okposo NYI RW 27 UFA 2016 $2,800,000 [*]Cam Atkinson CBJ RW 26 UFA 2018 $3,500,000 [*]Sami Vatanen ANA D 24 RFA 2016 $1,250,000 [*]Keith Yandle NYR D 29 UFA 2016 $2,625,000 [*]Cam Fowler ANA D 24 RFA 2018 $4,000,000 [*]Jiri Hudler CGY C/LW 33 UFA 2016 $4,000,000 [*]Loui Eriksson BOS RW 30 UFA 2016 $4,250,000 [*]Milan Lucic LAK LW 27 UFA 2016 $3,250,000 [*]Tyler Bozak TOR C 29 UFA 2019 $4,200,000 [*]Kris Russell CGY D 28 UFA 2016 $2,600,000 [/LIST]
I honestly don't understand why there are rumours around Shattenkirk. He has another year remaining on a bargain contract, his team is in the playoff hunt and he is one of their best defenseman. I could see David Backes being in play as he is a UFA.
At any rate, from this list, I would target Yandle, Okposo. If the Islanders would accept a forward prospect in return for Travis Hamonic I would do that, but all indications are they are looking for defense.
Why would you target anyone from that list (not named Drouin or RNH)? We desperately need to rebuild. Targeting UFA"s Yandle or Okposo would be counterproductive.
I was going to ask why this thread even had to exist But now that I see there's two buyers my question is have they actually watched the game versus Toronto on the weekend?
Why would you target anyone from that list (not named Drouin or RNH)? We desperately need to rebuild. Targeting UFA"s Yandle or Okposo would be counterproductive.
With Edler injured they really need Hamhuis. Their defense is struggling now without him they may as well blow it up. If they trade him they have given up, so I don't see them doing that. If Edler were healthy then maybe they could move him.
I am against getting late first round draft picks for players they can use, or just accumulating a bunch of picks. To me the draft is weak. McSaviour was sooo last year. I would much prefer the vets we trade return defensive prospects who play the right side. Now that Buff is off the table, there is no one on defense that I am excited about who are UFAs. Trading for a prospect is our best hope to fill a vital need. Looking at next year we could have a competitive D if we resign Hammer and get one good right side D:
Tanev Edler
NEED Hamhuis
Sbisa Hutton
Biega Pedan
My hope is their biggest NEED is filled at the trade deadline.