Proposal: New Jersey - Edmonton - Carolina

[Nico the Draft Riser]

New Jersey receives: Darnell Nurse

Edmonton receives:Noah Hanifin, Damon Severson

Carolina receives: #17, Ryan Nugent-Hopkins


So Edmonton replaces Nurse (NJ would prefer Nurse's playstyle) with Hanifin and get a RH PMD who can PPQB. They gave up Nurse and RNH. Carolina gets RNH; a young 1/2C who fits their style and another first round pick to keep/trade. They move one of their young d, which they have an abundance of, for a need by giving up Noah Hanifin. New Jersey receis Nurse as they need a young top 4 LHD to grow into a top pair and give up Severson and the #17 pick to do so.

I tried to handle needs as well as fair value. Thoughts? If cap is needed to be moved we can figure that out

Click to read more...

 

[McSuper]

No from Edmonton side

 

[Zajacs Bowl Cut]

RNH and Nurse for Hanifin and Severson is not a good deal for Edmonton

 

[Meeqs]

Why even add NJD here to over complicate things. Like is most of these, cut out the garbage and its clear its not happening.

 

[780il]

Big no from Edmonton.

 

[rockinghockey]

I would rather have RNH and Nurse than those two
Severson doesn’t have thst trade value

 

[Nico the Draft Riser]

RNH and Nurse for Hanifin and Severson is not a good deal for Edmonton

How so? You dont think Severson and RNH have similar value?

 

[ConnorMcNugesaitl]

How so? You dont think Severson and RNH have similar value?

nope

 

[Chan790]

Also a easy "No" for Carolina. No interest in a mid-round 1st or RNH in a Hanifin trade.

It's just not what we're looking for Hanifin.

 

[Nico the Draft Riser]

nope

than we agree to disagree! Severson is 23 signed for five years at an amazing cap

 

[bl02]

Hey Edmonton traded the MVP of the league for Adam Larsson so why not

 

[Nico the Draft Riser]

Also a easy "No" for Carolina. No interest in a mid-round 1st or RNH in a Hanifin trade.

It's just not what we're looking for Hanifin.

I was told by numerous Carolina fans that a young top 6 center is needed if Hanifin goes. RNH is exactly that

 

[Chan790]

I was told by numerous Carolina fans that a young top 6 center is needed if Hanifin goes. RNH is exactly that

Preference is to move Faulk.

Someone would have to offer a dynamic, young offensive C with not top-6 but 1C potential to convince the brain-trust to move Hanifin instead.

There is probably no Hanifin trade that makes sense for the other team...but the Canes will listen to offers.

 

[A91]

How so? You dont think Severson and RNH have similar value?

God no

 

[A91]

Hey Edmonton traded the MVP of the league for Adam Larsson so why not

The "MVP"
We all know who the real league MVP is

 

[Nico the Draft Riser]

God no

why not exactly?

Id like to hear a reason or two

 

[Zajacs Bowl Cut]

The "MVP"
We all know who the real league MVP is

yes, Taylor Hall

you'll see in 2 days

 

[A91]

why not exactly?

Id like to hear a reason or two

Do you think Zibanejad and Severson are equal in value?

Because RNH is superior to Zibanejad in literally all aspects of the game.

 

[Smitty426]

than we agree to disagree! Severson is 23 signed for five years at an amazing cap

And that's a Ranger fan giving a Devs playing props! Well played Jorge!

 

[Nico the Draft Riser]

And that's a Ranger fan giving a Devs playing props! Well played Jorge!

Lmao Im a Devils fan, I lost a bet

 

[voxel]

This is terrible for the Oilers. The OP doesn’t understand we need to ship out a D in the future because of cap. After that trade we have

Larsson-Klefbom
Sekera-Russell
Severson-Hanifin

Where does 21pt Matt Benning fit? He has only 3 fewer points than Severson last season. And what about Ethan Bear or Caleb Jones?

If anything Oilers need 1-1 D trade.

 

[Smitty426]

Lmao Im a Devils fan, I lost a bet

Ooof, that's bad bro, props anyway. You buds must be laughing at this thread specifically!

 

[yababy]

New Jersey receives: Darnell Nurse

Edmonton receives:Noah Hanifin, Damon Severson

Carolina receives: #17, Ryan Nugent-Hopkins


So Edmonton replaces Nurse (NJ would prefer Nurse's playstyle) with Hanifin and get a RH PMD who can PPQB. They gave up Nurse and RNH. Carolina gets RNH; a young 1/2C who fits their style and another first round pick to keep/trade. They move one of their young d, which they have an abundance of, for a need by giving up Noah Hanifin. New Jersey receis Nurse as they need a young top 4 LHD to grow into a top pair and give up Severson and the #17 pick to do so.

I tried to handle needs as well as fair value. Thoughts? If cap is needed to be moved we can figure that out

No way Oilers trade Nurse for Hanafin

 

[Nico the Draft Riser]

This is terrible for the Oilers. The OP doesn’t understand we need to ship out a D in the future because of cap. After that trade we have

Larsson-Klefbom
Sekera-Russell
Severson-Hanifin

Where does 21pt Matt Benning fit? He has only 3 fewer points than Severson last season. And what about Ethan Bear or Caleb Jones?

If anything Oilers need 1-1 D trade.

You didnt even get their sides right

 

[ChaoticOrange]

How so? You dont think Severson and RNH have similar value?

Uh, no? Because they don’t?

Nurse > Hanifin
RNH >> Severson

Nurse is playing top pairing minutes in Edmonton, Hanifin cannot step in and do that. Severson is no better than a #4. Your deal is a big loss for us. Deal with the Hurricanes and cut us out of it.