A) using all strengths heavily weighs in PK starts and PP starts. Guhle does kill penalties yes, but not particularly well (it's one of my biggest concerns about him)
So you're saying Calgary will give us Florida's 1st pick in 2025, so we get their 2025 1st pick, which could easily be a top 10 pick?
Bad results? Bad on the pk??? Do you watch hockey?? Guhle have played great hockey again the best each day. His on ice play is the opposit of bad result.
The trade is a farce. It will never happen. OP is trying to get the 9th OA pick this year, plus Calgary's 1st next year, which could be 2nd overall.
Objectively, with Kaiden Guhle on the ice, Montreal does not generate many chances, and they give up a large number of chances against. This isn't Guhle's fault. As both of us have said, he isn't put in a great situation to succeed. But we cannot pretend that Guhle is getting great on ice results, because he simply isn't.
I have watched plenty of Guhle. He is a very good young dman.
And you are trying to use habs poor advance stats to downplay Guhle. Of course they get outscored and outchanced, their a bottom team. Guhle have nothing to do with it. And I don't think he is a top pairing dman like I don't think Nemec is too.
I'm not. I have consistently said that what guhle has done in a tough role is very admirable. But if you're going to bring up his very tough assignments, you also need to acknowledge the lack of overall success in those assignments.
The Flames literally can't trade that Florida pick or their own 2025 and 2026 1st round picks because they are all locked because they are in a conditional trade that will not be resolved until end of next season.
And thats where I know that you didnt see him play even if you say so. Saying it was a lack of success is the opposite of the truth. Is personal play was a success, the team result was not and nothing he could have done would have changed that.
You appear to be misunderstanding what I mean by on ice results. The teams results were not good with guhle on the ice, the teams results were not good with guhle off the ice. Guhle played quite admirably
I think slightly better results yeah. Although it's tough to say how a 19 year old will fare in situations like that.
Of course you think that. I don't even know why I asked. Oh and just for you 5v5. Like a said, not close
You realize the zone starts difference amounts to 0.4 offensive zone starts per game and about 1.3 defensive zone starts per game right? (assuming 30 shifts per game)
Exactly. Any Habs fans turning this down are crazy to me. It would be Guhle for two top ten picks with odds being that the Flames pick will be even higher next year.
I find it funny that Calgary 2025 1st is already a top 10 protected pick (but on the other side of protection) and that there’s no way they would ever overachieve and be a bubble team.
Markstrom will be gone this summer. Huberdeau is cooked. I'd set the over under at 55 points for him. Wolf is the X factor. He's our only potentially elite piece. If Wolf goes Shesterkin of 2 years ago then we could be a bubble playoff team. We got career 30 goal seasons from Coleman, Sharangovich and Kadri. I guess you could expect more from Mangiapane and Andersson typically than we got this year, but pretty much everyone else played to the normal level or higher.
Nemec was in no way sheltered this year. He played 1st pair because Hamilton went down for the season, then he played even more tough minutes when Marino went down. That kid is going to be as good as Ekblad, Slavin, and prime Ellis.
