as a flyers fan, richards has far exceeded my expectaions from a rookie so far. he can play in any situation, is very aggressive, and has shown great puck poise. he had 2 points last night, and he was all over the ice. carter has seemed like hes lacked intensity, and may be struggling with confidence. he almost looked overwhelmed in the first couple of games. right now, richards is head and shoulders above carter, no question. i know many experts think carter will eventually be a more dominating offensive player, but from what i've seen of richards this season and last, richards has shown way more offensive upside then expected, and could definitely develope into a 1st line center.