Marner, Keller or Hischier

[zharkenby]

I’m a devils fan and voted Nico last year, but marners taken another step. Him AINEC

 

[zharkenby]

LMAO. This one is so obviously Marner, it's hilarious to see the posts and results.

You people are funny.

I mean.. I believe this is a year old. Last year these results were more than reasonable

 

[JetsWillFly4Ever]

January of last year Marner was off to an average start and Hischier was performing well as an 18 year old first overall pick, it was reasonable to pick Hischier then.

Now, Marner has taken a big step forward that Hischier has yet to match, it is clearly Marner now.

but but but Leaaaaf haaaateeeee

 

[CantLoseWithMatthews]

January of last year Marner was off to an average start and Hischier was performing well as an 18 year old first overall pick, it was reasonable to pick Hischier then.

Now, Marner has taken a big step forward that Hischier has yet to match, it is clearly Marner now.

but but but Leaaaaf haaaateeeee

Picking Hischier or Keller is fine. Saying Marner is a tier behind and shouldn't even be in the conversation takes some bias. I don't think anyone was saying that though, so there's probably no point complaining

 

[JetsWillFly4Ever]

Picking Hischier or Keller is fine. Saying Marner is a tier behind and shouldn't even be in the conversation takes some bias though

Yeah, Marner was never a tier below and now is pretty clearly a tier above imo.

 

[CantLoseWithMatthews]

Yeah, Marner was never a tier below and now is pretty clearly a tier above imo.

Looking through the thread, I don't think anyone called marner a tier behind. So yeah the outrage is unwarranted

 

[JetsWillFly4Ever]

Looking through the thread, I don't think anyone called marner a tier behind. So yeah the outrage is unwarranted

There were a few, mostly trolls looking to stir the pot, in the same manner there were a few Leaf fans trying to stir the pot by saying Marner at the time was clearly way ahead. Typical HF shit.

Marner is way ahead now though.

 

[34]

Marner is better than, and will win polls with much better players than the particular ones in this thread.

I will add, I am a Keller fan as well.

 

[CantLoseWithMatthews]

There were a few, mostly trolls looking to stir the pot, in the same manner there were a few Leaf fans trying to stir the pot by saying Marner at the time was clearly way ahead. Typical HF ****.

Marner is way ahead now though.

I agree he's way ahead for now, but he's also older. I remember when flames fans acted like it was ridiculous to compare marner and gaudreau. Age really does matter at this stage

 

[34]

I agree he's way ahead for now, but he's also older. I remember when flames fans acted like it was ridiculous to compare marner and gaudreau. Age really does matter at this stage

Its Marner >> Gaudreau quite comfortably.

 

[Wayne Primeau]

Its Marner >> Gaudreau quite comfortably.

I'd object to that. It's a four-point difference and Gaudreau has twice the goals.

 

[34]

I'd object to that. It's a four-point difference and Gaudreau has twice the goals.

Strongly disagree. I take Marner over Gaudreau quite easily. He is way more dynamic and skilled.

 

[Wayne Primeau]

Strongly disagree. I take Marner over Gaudreau quite easily. He is way more dynamic and skilled.

That's pretty subjective, I must say. I guarantee you don't watch very much Gaudreau.

 

[34]

That's pretty subjective, I must say. I guarantee you don't watch very much Gaudreau.

I do, when we get the games here in Toronto. He is a great player, I am not trying to take away from him... but Marner is on another level.