Lets step back a bit... Kuemper won a cup with dynamic generational talent leading the way. That's a massive piece of context missing.
Sure, if we have a Makar and MacKinnon to pay instead of a goalie, I'm for it.
Igor either plays lights out and earns his $10-11M contract, which is great for the team over the next two years.... or he's inconsistent and gets around 8M.
I have no dog in this fight. I want this team to win. If we can find a serviceable replacement for less, great. If we end up like Toronto, New Jersey or Edmonton.... not great.
If Benoit Allaire is as great as we think he is, he most likely doesn't need a 11M goalie.
We have Fox - as close of a comparable player as you can get.
We have a lot of firepower up front that are already paid. If Panarin can regain his early season form once playoffs roll around things will be exciting.
Makar and MacKinnon weren't winners until they won. MacKinnon gave that presser about "Well I've been in the league for 8-9 years and haven't won shit." I don't think Colorado made it past the 2nd round during those 8-9 years.
We have comparable players up and down the roster - maybe no one in the mold of a MacKinnon/Tkachuk who, as one player, can fill multiple roles that we need 2 to fill, but not every winner is a carbon copy of every other winner and I'm not sure it's essential to building a Cup winner. Certainly doesn't hurt though.
I think Zibanejad is the lynchpin of this team's playoff success and would be that sort of gamebreaking player for us. If he goes into the playoffs with a fire lit under his ass (and everyone else's play stays more or less the same), Rangers cruise to the ECF.