I just think that a new HC needs to have a chance to work with this core sure a piece can be moved but I don's see this org going nuclear and rebuilding at least not next year
Is this a prediction thread or one where people are expressing their take on what should be done?
I don't see this org going nuclear either. Whether they should or not is another question. I'm not sure of the answer. Some have expressed the idea that it would be unfair to the new coach to expect him to come in and clean up this mess. Another idea I am unsure of.
Lets look at it piece by piece and see what it adds up to.
All new coaching staff? check
Move Scheifele? check
New captain? check
That could be all that is required in terms of the rebuild/retool. But I think that if we take the C from Wheeler we should probably move him too, if possible. That is unless he is onboard with that change. I don't expect that he will be though. JMO. Assuming he does not like giving up the C, he would probably expand his list of acceptable landing places. I think that if we retain heavily (I would go to 50% if necessary) there would be some teams willing to give up something worthwhile in exchange. He is still a near ppg, big bodied, RW who can also play C. At 4.25 mil for just 2 more years, there should be teams that would want him.
There is more that is not directly related to that culture change. I think we should move both Dillon and Schmidt. In hindsight, we never should have acquired them. We could have kept the picks, the money and the cap space and filled the holes internally. Water under the bridge now, but lets get rid of the money and the cap space and fill the spots, either internally or in return on some of the trades. They are just in the way now.
I could stop there. Is that a rebuild or a retool? Scheifele, Wheeler, Dillon and Schmidt out. It may depend on the returns to define it as either. Futures, it is a rebuild. Replacement players, it is a retool.
The one remaining question in my mind is Hellebuyck. If we are going to compete within 2 years, I guess we should keep him. But if not, he would bring a substantial return. The other gotcha there would be if Helle has decided he wants out. Gotta trade him sooner rather than later in that case. And if we move Helle it
IS a rebuild.
Edit: BTW, if we move Helle and Stastny does not return, we have moved the 6 oldest players on the current roster. Lowry #6 and DeMelo is #8. They would become #s 1&2 after those moves, unless we get older players in the returns somewhere.