TheDevilMadeMe
Registered User
Round 1 List
Rank | name
1 | Wayne Gretzky
2 | Jean Beliveau
3 | Stan Mikita
4 | Mario Lemieux
5 | Steve Yzerman
6 | Mark Messier
7 | Joe Sakic
8 | Bryan Trottier
9 | Marcel Dionne
10 | Sergei Fedorov
11 | Cyclone Taylor
12 | Howie Morenz
13 | Peter Forsberg
14 | Bobby Clarke
15 | Phil Esposito
16 | Frank Nighbor
17 | Sidney Crosby
18 | Milt Schmidt
19 | Henri Richard
20 | Newsy Lalonde
21 | Doug Gilmour
22 | Syl Apps, Sr
23 | Ron Francis
24 | Peter Statsny
25 | Alex Delvecchio
26 | Frank Boucher
27 | Igor Larionov
28 | Eric Lindros
29 | Joe Malone
30 | Dale Hawerchuk
31 | Norm Ullman
32 | Dave Keon
33 | Pavel Datsyuk
34 | Max Bentley
35 | Adam Oates
36 | Sid Abel
37 | Evgeni Malkin
38 | Mike Modano
39 | Elmer Lach
40 | Denis Savard
41 | Joe Thornton
42 | Jacques Lemaire
43 | Mats Sundin
44 | Bill Cowley
45 | Henrik Zetterberg
46 | Marty Barry
47 | Jean Ratelle
48 | Gilbert Perreault
49 | Joe Primeau
50 | Nels Stewart
51 | Jeremy Roenick
52 | Mickey MacKay
53 | Darryl Sittler
54 | Pat Lafontaine
55 | Bernie Federko
56 | Vaclav Nedmoansky
57 | Steven Stamkos
58 | Pierre Turgeon
59 | Joe Niewendyk
60 | Guy Carbonneau
61 | Ted Kennedy
62 | Rod Brind'Amour
63 | Kent Nilsson
64 | Hooley Smith
65 | Bernie Nicholls
66 | Henrik Sedin
67 | Frank Fredrickson
68 | Russel Bowie
69 | Duke Keats
70 | Bernie Morris
71 | Brad Richards
72 | Eric Staal
73 | Rick MacLeish
74 | Doug Weight
75 | Vladmir Petrov
76 | Bobby Smith
77 | Alexander Maltsev
78 | Saku Koivu
79 | Ulf Nilsson
80 | Butch Goring
Players from our final top 60 not ranked in this top 60
Ted Kennedy at 61
Hooley Smith at 64
Frank Fredrickson at 67
Russell Bowie at 68
Duke Keats at 69
Vladimir Petrov at 75
Alexander Maltsev at 77
Neil Colville (not ranked)
Players unique to this list
Eric Staal (on 1 other list)
Doug Weight (on 1 other list)
Saku Koivu
Ulf Nilsson
Players ranked highest overall on this list
Jean Beliveau at 2 - next highest at 3
Stan Mikita at 3 - next highest at 4
Steve Yzerman at 5 - next highest at 10
Joe Sakic at 7 - next highest at 8
Marcel Dionne at 9 - next highest at 14
Sergei Fedorov at 10 - next highest at 19
Peter Forsberg at 13 - next highest at 17
Doug Gilmour at 21 - next highest at 22
Igor Larionov at 27 - next highest at 29
Mats Sundin at 43 - next highest at 44
Jeremy Roenick at 51 - next highest at 54
Kent Nilsson at 63 (tied with 1 other)
Bernie Nicholls at 65 - next highest at 68
Brad Richards at 71 - next highest at 72
Players ranked 2nd highest on this list
Sidney Crosby at 17
Ron Francis at 23 (tied with 1 other)
Eric Lindros at 28
Mike Modano at 38
Jacques Lemaire at 42
Henrik Zetterberg at 45
Bernie Federko at 55
Pierre Turgeon at 58
Players ranked lowest overall on this list
Mario Lemieux at 4 - next lowest at 2
Howie Morenz at 12 - next lowest at 8
Bobby Clarke at 14 - next lowest at 11
Nels Stewart at 50 - next lowest at 46
Ted Kennedy at 61 - next lowest at 42
Russell Bowie at 68 - next lowest at 57
Vladimir Petrov at 75 - next lowest at 72
Alexander Maltsev at 77 - next lowest at 63
Tommy Dunderdale - not ranked
Players ranked 2nd lowest on this list
Phil Esposito at 15 (tied with 1 other)
Frank Boucher at 26
Hooley Smith at 64
Frank Fredrickson at 67
Round 2 voting
Round | 1st | 2nd | 3rd | 4th | 5th | 6th | 7th | 8th | none
1 | Gretzky | Beliveau | Mikita | Morenz | Lemieux | Messier | Trottier | Clarke | Esposito
2 | Mikita | Messier | Sakic | Trottier | Taylor | Yzerman | Clarke | Nighbor | Esposito, Lalonde
3 | Sakic | Yzerman | Trottier | Taylor | Dionne | Esposito | Lalonde | Apps | Schmidt
4 | Yzerman | Forsberg | Dionne | Richard | Apps | Boucher | Lalonde | Malone | Schmidt
5 | Forsberg | Crosby | Dionne | Fedorov | Richard | Malone | Schmidt | Kennedy | Bentley
6 | Crosby | Fedorov | Kennedy | Stastny | Lach | Ullman | Malone | Stewart | Abel, Bentley, Cowley, Keon
7 | Fedorov | Stastny | Ullman | Francis | Stewart | Lach | Bentley | Abel | Cowley, Delvecchio, Keon
8 | Fedorov | Stewart | Lindros | Stastny | Francis | Gilmour | Keon | Abel | Delvecchio, Oates, Perreault
9 | Lindros | Stastny | Francis | Gilmour | Thornton | Malkin | Oates | Hawerchuk | Delvecchio, Maltsev, Perreault
10 | Lindros | Datsyuk | Malkin | Oates | Larionov | Hawerchuk | Perreault | Delvecchio | Bowie, Ratelle, Smith
11 | Datsyuk | Malkin | Modano | Hawerchuk | Larionov | Perreault | Savard | Ratelle | Bowie, MacKay, Petrov, Smith
12 | Modano | Hawerchuk | Sundin | Larionov | Savard | Petrov | Ratelle | MacKay | Barry, Fredrickson, Primeau, Sittler
13 | Zetterberg | Sundin | Larionov | Savard | Lafontaine | Sittler | Petrov | MacKay | Fredrickson, Keats, Lemaire, Nedomansky, Primeau
14 | Sundin | Zetterberg | Lafontaine | Lemaire | Sittler | Sedin | Fredrickson | Nedomansky | Dunderdale, Foyston, Keats, McGee, Morris, Primeau
15 | Roenick | Lafontaine | Lemaire | Stamkos | Sedin | Turgeon | Brind'Amour | Keats | Carbonneau, Colville, Dunderdale, Federko, Foyston, McGee, Morris, Nieuwendyk, Novy, Primeau, Starshinov
16 | Roenick | Sedin | Lafontaine | Colville | Foyston | Primeau | | |
Highest vote
Round 1: Mikita 3rd
Round 5: Fedorov 4th
Round 6: Fedorov 2nd
Round 9: Lindros 1st
Round 12: Sundin 3rd
Round 15: Roenick 1st
Lowest vote
Round 1: Lemieux 5th
Round 5: Schmidt 7th
Round 7: Bentley 7th
Round 12: Barry NR
1 | Wayne Gretzky
2 | Jean Beliveau
3 | Stan Mikita
4 | Mario Lemieux
5 | Steve Yzerman
6 | Mark Messier
7 | Joe Sakic
8 | Bryan Trottier
9 | Marcel Dionne
10 | Sergei Fedorov
11 | Cyclone Taylor
12 | Howie Morenz
13 | Peter Forsberg
14 | Bobby Clarke
15 | Phil Esposito
16 | Frank Nighbor
17 | Sidney Crosby
18 | Milt Schmidt
19 | Henri Richard
20 | Newsy Lalonde
21 | Doug Gilmour
22 | Syl Apps, Sr
23 | Ron Francis
24 | Peter Statsny
25 | Alex Delvecchio
26 | Frank Boucher
27 | Igor Larionov
28 | Eric Lindros
29 | Joe Malone
30 | Dale Hawerchuk
31 | Norm Ullman
32 | Dave Keon
33 | Pavel Datsyuk
34 | Max Bentley
35 | Adam Oates
36 | Sid Abel
37 | Evgeni Malkin
38 | Mike Modano
39 | Elmer Lach
40 | Denis Savard
41 | Joe Thornton
42 | Jacques Lemaire
43 | Mats Sundin
44 | Bill Cowley
45 | Henrik Zetterberg
46 | Marty Barry
47 | Jean Ratelle
48 | Gilbert Perreault
49 | Joe Primeau
50 | Nels Stewart
51 | Jeremy Roenick
52 | Mickey MacKay
53 | Darryl Sittler
54 | Pat Lafontaine
55 | Bernie Federko
56 | Vaclav Nedmoansky
57 | Steven Stamkos
58 | Pierre Turgeon
59 | Joe Niewendyk
60 | Guy Carbonneau
61 | Ted Kennedy
62 | Rod Brind'Amour
63 | Kent Nilsson
64 | Hooley Smith
65 | Bernie Nicholls
66 | Henrik Sedin
67 | Frank Fredrickson
68 | Russel Bowie
69 | Duke Keats
70 | Bernie Morris
71 | Brad Richards
72 | Eric Staal
73 | Rick MacLeish
74 | Doug Weight
75 | Vladmir Petrov
76 | Bobby Smith
77 | Alexander Maltsev
78 | Saku Koivu
79 | Ulf Nilsson
80 | Butch Goring
Players from our final top 60 not ranked in this top 60
Ted Kennedy at 61
Hooley Smith at 64
Frank Fredrickson at 67
Russell Bowie at 68
Duke Keats at 69
Vladimir Petrov at 75
Alexander Maltsev at 77
Neil Colville (not ranked)
Players unique to this list
Eric Staal (on 1 other list)
Doug Weight (on 1 other list)
Saku Koivu
Ulf Nilsson
Players ranked highest overall on this list
Jean Beliveau at 2 - next highest at 3
Stan Mikita at 3 - next highest at 4
Steve Yzerman at 5 - next highest at 10
Joe Sakic at 7 - next highest at 8
Marcel Dionne at 9 - next highest at 14
Sergei Fedorov at 10 - next highest at 19
Peter Forsberg at 13 - next highest at 17
Doug Gilmour at 21 - next highest at 22
Igor Larionov at 27 - next highest at 29
Mats Sundin at 43 - next highest at 44
Jeremy Roenick at 51 - next highest at 54
Kent Nilsson at 63 (tied with 1 other)
Bernie Nicholls at 65 - next highest at 68
Brad Richards at 71 - next highest at 72
Players ranked 2nd highest on this list
Sidney Crosby at 17
Ron Francis at 23 (tied with 1 other)
Eric Lindros at 28
Mike Modano at 38
Jacques Lemaire at 42
Henrik Zetterberg at 45
Bernie Federko at 55
Pierre Turgeon at 58
Players ranked lowest overall on this list
Mario Lemieux at 4 - next lowest at 2
Howie Morenz at 12 - next lowest at 8
Bobby Clarke at 14 - next lowest at 11
Nels Stewart at 50 - next lowest at 46
Ted Kennedy at 61 - next lowest at 42
Russell Bowie at 68 - next lowest at 57
Vladimir Petrov at 75 - next lowest at 72
Alexander Maltsev at 77 - next lowest at 63
Tommy Dunderdale - not ranked
Players ranked 2nd lowest on this list
Phil Esposito at 15 (tied with 1 other)
Frank Boucher at 26
Hooley Smith at 64
Frank Fredrickson at 67
Round 2 voting
1 | Gretzky | Beliveau | Mikita | Morenz | Lemieux | Messier | Trottier | Clarke | Esposito
2 | Mikita | Messier | Sakic | Trottier | Taylor | Yzerman | Clarke | Nighbor | Esposito, Lalonde
3 | Sakic | Yzerman | Trottier | Taylor | Dionne | Esposito | Lalonde | Apps | Schmidt
4 | Yzerman | Forsberg | Dionne | Richard | Apps | Boucher | Lalonde | Malone | Schmidt
5 | Forsberg | Crosby | Dionne | Fedorov | Richard | Malone | Schmidt | Kennedy | Bentley
6 | Crosby | Fedorov | Kennedy | Stastny | Lach | Ullman | Malone | Stewart | Abel, Bentley, Cowley, Keon
7 | Fedorov | Stastny | Ullman | Francis | Stewart | Lach | Bentley | Abel | Cowley, Delvecchio, Keon
8 | Fedorov | Stewart | Lindros | Stastny | Francis | Gilmour | Keon | Abel | Delvecchio, Oates, Perreault
9 | Lindros | Stastny | Francis | Gilmour | Thornton | Malkin | Oates | Hawerchuk | Delvecchio, Maltsev, Perreault
10 | Lindros | Datsyuk | Malkin | Oates | Larionov | Hawerchuk | Perreault | Delvecchio | Bowie, Ratelle, Smith
11 | Datsyuk | Malkin | Modano | Hawerchuk | Larionov | Perreault | Savard | Ratelle | Bowie, MacKay, Petrov, Smith
12 | Modano | Hawerchuk | Sundin | Larionov | Savard | Petrov | Ratelle | MacKay | Barry, Fredrickson, Primeau, Sittler
13 | Zetterberg | Sundin | Larionov | Savard | Lafontaine | Sittler | Petrov | MacKay | Fredrickson, Keats, Lemaire, Nedomansky, Primeau
14 | Sundin | Zetterberg | Lafontaine | Lemaire | Sittler | Sedin | Fredrickson | Nedomansky | Dunderdale, Foyston, Keats, McGee, Morris, Primeau
15 | Roenick | Lafontaine | Lemaire | Stamkos | Sedin | Turgeon | Brind'Amour | Keats | Carbonneau, Colville, Dunderdale, Federko, Foyston, McGee, Morris, Nieuwendyk, Novy, Primeau, Starshinov
16 | Roenick | Sedin | Lafontaine | Colville | Foyston | Primeau | | |
Highest vote
Round 1: Mikita 3rd
Round 5: Fedorov 4th
Round 6: Fedorov 2nd
Round 9: Lindros 1st
Round 12: Sundin 3rd
Round 15: Roenick 1st
Lowest vote
Round 1: Lemieux 5th
Round 5: Schmidt 7th
Round 7: Bentley 7th
Round 12: Barry NR
Last edited: