I think we have 1 prospect with "star" potential, which is Wallstedt.
After that you've got probably 6-8 with hopes/expectations/potential of top 6 forward or top 4 defense, which is: Rossi, Yurov, Faber, Khusnuts, Ohgren, Lambos, Peart (maybe) and Stramel (maybe). All of these guys would be on the same relative "tier", in that case, IMO.
Of those guys, only Rossi and Faber have seen any NHL games, of which Rossi did not show well, and Faber did, depending on how much you want to get into the "sheltered" argument.
Seeing Faber in those 8 games, I feel reasonably assured that Faber's floor is now at least NHL player. I feel good about that, and I don't feel like it's controversial. Based on that, I would not entirely blame anybody for moving Faber towards the top of that 2nd "tier" for the time being, especially if if they value the "floor" in any meaningful way (I don't put a lot into it, but I don't completely ignore it either).
In any case, it's not like Faber beat Rossi in a landslide (3 votes) and who knows how many of those Rossi votes would've gone to Yurov, had Rossi prevailed at #2. It's not the Crime of the Century here.