Ray Martyniuk
Registered User
- Mar 13, 2019
- 5,275
- 1,316
I could see a poor man's Tavares. He's not as dynamic as Seguin or as well rounded as Toews IMO.
I think Seguin is very dynamic. Explosive skating, great ability to handle the puck at top speed, ability to blow by defenders.Seguin's not dynamic? He's a shooter who doesn't exactly dangle a lot or create highlight reel passes for his teammates.
Unless we just have different definitions of dynamic.
lolIf Arizona wins the Shane Wright rights should they trade him to TO for A Matthews...yes!
I think Seguin was very dynamic. Explosive skating, great ability to handle the puck at top speed, ability to blow by defenders.
That's probably fair. I'm thinking of comps in terms of players in their prime.Fixed this for you. He was all these things but his injury history has caught up with him. He's lost more than a couple steps now.
Guys like Hintz, Gurianov and Heiskanen are also way faster than Seguin ever was.Fixed this for you. He was all these things but his injury history has caught up with him. He's lost more than a couple steps now.
I'm not sure what this has to do with the conversation about Seguin being dynamic or not.Guys like Hintz, Gurianov and Heiskanen are also way faster than Seguin ever was.
Fixed this for you. He was all these things but his injury history has caught up with him. He's lost more than a couple steps now.
People are just looking to throw their hot takes out there. It’s easy to nitpick a player that’s been playing at an elite level for years. They rarely will receive more credit at this point. He’s going first and deserves to, barring a season where he’s not above 1PPG.
as somebody who has watched hischier play since his rookie year, i would not say that he is a good comp to wright. wright is much more of an offensive threat + to go along with his offensive awareness and playmaking ability he is a nice shooting threat as well. hischier is not a shooting threat whatsoever and while they may be comparable in the sense that they play a two way game, i would say that wright has a higher ceiling. hischier is yet to reach a high end 2c in terms of offensive production.Elite 2C? Hischier?
as somebody who has watched hischier play since his rookie year, i would not say that he is a good comp to wright. wright is much more of an offensive threat + to go along with his offensive awareness and playmaking ability he is a nice shooting threat as well. hischier is not a shooting threat whatsoever and while they may be comparable in the sense that they play a two way game, i would say that wright has a higher ceiling. hischier is yet to reach a high end 2c in terms of offensive production.
I meant more in that high pick range but not offensive enough to be a 1C...but your point(s) are valid
I meant more in that high pick range but not offensive enough to be a 1C...but your point(s) are valid
I don't know why people keep saying the bolded. Wright's shown at every level he's played at that he absolutely has the potential to be a 1C, and a high-end 1C at that.
He had almost 40 goals as a 15/16 year old on a bad Kingston team.
He absolutely lit up the U-18s.
And even with his "slow start", he's still well above a point per game and is about 12th in overall league scoring. So it's not even like he's not producing at all.
Will he be on the Crosby/McDavid tier? Likely not. But he's given no indications for anyone to believe he can't be in a similar tier to the next tier down from that.
Not improving statistically over what he as done as a 15/16 years old should at least make you raise an eyebrow.
I can't say I a have an opinion on him either way as I don't really watch junior hockey, but statistically speaking, it reminds me of Nolan Patrick. I understand Wright was a much bigger contributor, relatively speaking, than Patrick at the same age, but what bothers me is how he's trending.
We'll see how the season unfolds, but if he maintains that sort of PPG through the year, I don't know why you shouldn't question his status as the definitive 1st overall. His 15 years old season should be irrelevant at this point.